Live data from Hacker News

Team led by Japanese researchers reveals best way to put crying baby to sleep

mainichi.jp

21–30 of 71 posts

Re: Team led by Japanese researchers reveals best way to put crying baby to sleep

#21
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

human physical contact ftw. All these devices are just a substitute for a mother.

Or any loving human. My kids fell sleep easily on me, their father.

yeah, but breastfeeding works the best/easiest, which obviously ain't very suitable for men, my kids never used pacifiers (and pretty much never milk bottles), they just refused them

Re: Team led by Japanese researchers reveals best way to put crying baby to sleep

#22
post #2

As someone with a newborn, thank you for sharing this!

I've heard a lot of good things about the https://www.happiestbaby.com/products/snoo-smart-bassinet . It's expensive but my first child slept terribly; I'm not taking chances with my second.

Was very effective for a couple i know, so much so that the baby had a very flat head from sleeping so much

Re: Team led by Japanese researchers reveals best way to put crying baby to sleep

#24
post #2

As someone with a newborn, thank you for sharing this!

I've heard a lot of good things about the https://www.happiestbaby.com/products/snoo-smart-bassinet . It's expensive but my first child slept terribly; I'm not taking chances with my second.

Every baby is different.

From our experience - and of course every baby is different - we found consistency is key. New borns need to nap like every hour and you as parents need to actively manage those naps to make sure they happen at the right time, and you do the same set of things each time so soon enough baby knows that when you do foo that sleep time is coming and they calm down. Foo could be singing or a special story or getting into a sleep sack or music or whatever. Then just into a normal cot and they slept soundly.

The other thing we found that was essential is a £10 gym/yoga ball to slowly bounce/jiggle on while holding them. Worked really well for us (as part of the routine).

Good luck. Perhaps as every baby is different you really need the 2k cot, good luck either way.

Re: Team led by Japanese researchers reveals best way to put crying baby to sleep

#25
post #9

I've found a little trick when my newborn cries or gets unsettled while sleeping.. whenever she makes a noise I just go over and pat her. it moves the gases around and she's settled instantly. in order to put her asleep I usually just wheel her back and forwards in the pram, taking her over the edge of the rug (for the bump) usually stops her from crying. When she was really little, I used to have to walk to get her…

Yeah at the early stages the cries seem to just be gas, food, nappy, or attention.

We found that "la pause" is quite effective - let them fuss for up to a minute or so rather than rushing to the cot to intervene. A lot of the time they can work it out themselves without any help.

Re: Team led by Japanese researchers reveals best way to put crying baby to sleep

#26
We found swaddles with velcro to be really helpful for our kids to fall and stay asleep. We tried a few but the SwaddleMe's [1] worked the best. The baby would manage to work their arm out of the others we tried...and once their arm is out it is game over...their startle reflex wakes them up.

Once they outgrow the swaddle, the Merlin Magic Sleepsuits [2] were amazing. Bonus...you can't stop laughing at how silly they look while wearing them [3].

[1] https://www.amazon.com/SwaddleMe-Original-Swaddle-Confetti-N...

[2] https://www.magicsleepsuit.com/collections/baby-merlins-magi...

[3] https://www.google.com/search?tbm=isch&q=merlin+magic+suits+...

Re: Team led by Japanese researchers reveals best way to put crying baby to sleep

#28
post #26

We found swaddles with velcro to be really helpful for our kids to fall and stay asleep. We tried a few but the SwaddleMe's [1] worked the best. The baby would manage to work their arm out of the others we tried...and once their arm is out it is game over...their startle reflex wakes them up. Once they outgrow the swaddle, the Merlin Magic Sleepsuits [2] were amazing. Bonus...you can't stop laughing at how silly they…

+1 to some sort of "engineered swaddle" that restrains the arms effectively.

We found "traditional" swaddles to be unreliable - once the arm/arms were out then it is only a matter of time before they hit themselves in the face with their arms, but swaddles with specific features to prevent the escape of the arms to work really well.

We used one called Miracle Swaddle for both our kids. Just make sure you stop using swaddles as soon as the kid can roll on their own.

Re: Team led by Japanese researchers reveals best way to put crying baby to sleep

#29
post #19

Meanigless study with only 21 babies, extremely small sample size to make some general statements. > Results showed that the most effective way to put a baby to sleep was to carry them and walk around for five minutes, sit and wait for five to eight minutes, then put them to bed. Also this is nice theory, we all know of course if you hold baby (and eventually walk) the baby can fall asleep, the problem is to put the…

1. It's an exploratory study which both confirms previous results and builds on them. Furthermore, a sample size of 21 is not too inherently small to draw conclusions - that would depend on the effect sizes between conditions...

2. The study is explicitly about whether or not the children stay asleep after the different proposed routines. This is one of the main points of the article and is directly addressed within:

"When an infant falls asleep in one’s arms or in a stroller, parents would then want to put the infant to bed. However, this laydown procedure often makes the infant alert again. In this study, 9 of 26 (34.6%) sleeping infants awoke by 20 s after the laydown, while the remaining 17 infants stayed asleep. "

https://www.cell.com/current-biology/pdf/S0960-9822(22)01363...

Why comment with a critique if you didn't even have a cursory look at the paper, or even understand what the dependant variables are?

Re: Team led by Japanese researchers reveals best way to put crying baby to sleep

#30
post #26

We found swaddles with velcro to be really helpful for our kids to fall and stay asleep. We tried a few but the SwaddleMe's [1] worked the best. The baby would manage to work their arm out of the others we tried...and once their arm is out it is game over...their startle reflex wakes them up. Once they outgrow the swaddle, the Merlin Magic Sleepsuits [2] were amazing. Bonus...you can't stop laughing at how silly they…

+1 to some sort of "engineered swaddle" that restrains the arms effectively. We found "traditional" swaddles to be unreliable - once the arm/arms were out then it is only a matter of time before they hit themselves in the face with their arms, but swaddles with specific features to prevent the escape of the arms to work really well. We used one called Miracle Swaddle for both our kids. Just make sure you stop using s…

> Just make sure you stop using swaddles as soon as the kid can roll on their own.

Good to call out for safety reasons. FYI - this is when we transitioned to the Merlin Sleepsuit which prevents them from turning over but does not fully restrain their arms.

Post reply on HN