Live data from Hacker News

ACM Makes Thousands of Research Articles Freely Available; Opens First 50 Years

acm.org

21–30 of 40 posts

Re: ACM Makes Thousands of Research Articles Freely Available; Opens First 50 Years

#21
post #5

On a related subject, does anyone know of a simple technique to download and save large quantities of all publicly available research articles?

Since it is available for free online, why not just download what you need? Their site has nice suggestions for related works anyway -- managing a big heap o' papers seems like a pain.

Re: ACM Makes Thousands of Research Articles Freely Available; Opens First 50 Years

#22
A lot of the digital libraries, open data sets & code repositories suffer the same (quite hard) problem: a lack of finding aids for humans. Just greet the user with the same boolean advanced search fields. ACM, IEEE, NASA-ADS, Arxiv, Genbank, etc. All are aware of open access and "researcher development", but no one has a better solution than cloud based capsule model ;)

Re: ACM Makes Thousands of Research Articles Freely Available; Opens First 50 Years

#23

I interviewed ACM's CEO recently on this topic, which has been shared previously: https://associationsnow.com/2022/05/the-way-things-were-why-... Quick note: They are planning on opening the whole archive in a few years but it is still a work in progress. The plan is for 2025 for the whole archive to be opened. They released the first 50 years now in part because it timed well to the 75th anniversary. Finally, the or…

Thanks for the article. I've wondered why they need to open access to these papers in tranches. I had imagined there is probably work to prepare each paper and possibly securing agreements?

> “Our goal is to have it open in a few years, but there’s very real costs associated with [the open-access work],” Hanson said. “We have models so that we can pay for it.”

This sort of confuses me even more. Is the "paying for it" talking about the work needed to be done to make each paper open-access, or is this talking about funding the ability to host the papers?

Just curious about what the costs are that are mentioned and the plan to cover those costs and how the results in needing to open access to papers in tranches. Maybe the model could be adopted by other journals, too?

Re: ACM Makes Thousands of Research Articles Freely Available; Opens First 50 Years

#26
post #3

This is great news, I have been rather annoyed in the past when I wanted to share stuff that were on the archive publicly. The last such example I can remember was Peter Naur's reasoning that it should not be computer science, but Datalogy: https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/365719.366510

In some languages it is datalogy :). For example Swedish: https://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datavetenskap

Peter Naur was Danish, and was successful in getting the term datalogy established in the Scandinavian languages. Although in recent years most institutions have stopped using it in English materials and adopted "computer science", I guess for greater international visibility. For example, the department Naur established at the University of Copenhagen, the Datalogisk Institut [1], is now branded as the Department of Computer Science [2] in English. Whereas when Naur was still running it, he called it the Datalogy Institute.

[1] https://di.ku.dk/

[2] https://di.ku.dk/english/

Re: ACM Makes Thousands of Research Articles Freely Available; Opens First 50 Years

#29

I interviewed ACM's CEO recently on this topic, which has been shared previously: https://associationsnow.com/2022/05/the-way-things-were-why-... Quick note: They are planning on opening the whole archive in a few years but it is still a work in progress. The plan is for 2025 for the whole archive to be opened. They released the first 50 years now in part because it timed well to the 75th anniversary. Finally, the or…

Thanks for the article. I've wondered why they need to open access to these papers in tranches. I had imagined there is probably work to prepare each paper and possibly securing agreements? > “Our goal is to have it open in a few years, but there’s very real costs associated with [the open-access work],” Hanson said. “We have models so that we can pay for it.” This sort of confuses me even more. Is the "paying for it…

While I don't want to speculate for ACM, I do know a lot about the association space and their business models as I have reported on this space for a decade. I would suggest that in a situation like this, "paying for it" probably refers to:

- Accounting for the loss in revenue from changing a service that was once commercial (as this would be an example of a loss of a "nondues revenue," something a lot of organizations are actually trying to increase so as to cut back their reliance on membership dues)

- Potential rights considerations (there are magazine articles with photos in that archive, for example, and many of those might have contracts/ownership considerations to work through)

- The labor of actually managing the transition (with something like this you wouldn't want to just run a script to open it up, you probably would have to double-check things, and there are simply a lot of things). They have to budget for any employee work used to handle this transition.

They emphasized to me in our interview, however, that the issue was not technical; I actually thought it might be given the amount of content there is, but as they're quoted as saying in the piece, the real work centered around the creative decision-making around actually making a call like this.

Post reply on HN