Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Data Science in Context – Peter Norvig's New Book

datascienceincontext.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

21–30 of 46 posts

Re: Data Science in Context – Peter Norvig's New Book

#21

Post by zelphirkalt »

wrp wrote: post #19

They should change the title. It is not a book for programmers about implementation of data science techniques. It is a book for managers about concerns surrounding the application of data science in various domains. The title should be something like "Social Concerns in the Application of Data Science."

Social concerns are as a concern for engineers, as they are for their managers. However, I agree on changing the title somewhat, in order to indicate, that this is not a book about computer programming.

Re: Data Science in Context – Peter Norvig's New Book

#22

Post by nanna »

jll29 wrote: post #3

I admire Peter Norvig's didactic and programming skills; but the poor typesetting makes this book harder to read than need be.

Typesetting seems fine to me? What's the issue? Wouldn't mind the lines being shorter but it's to be expected from a textbook.

Re: Data Science in Context – Peter Norvig's New Book

#23

Post by urthor »

wrp wrote: post #19

They should change the title. It is not a book for programmers about implementation of data science techniques. It is a book for managers about concerns surrounding the application of data science in various domains. The title should be something like "Social Concerns in the Application of Data Science."

It's a book for data scientists.

Data scientists are not software engineers.

They analyze data, they don't produce applications.

Not everything in the world is written for the benefit of software engineers.

Re: Data Science in Context – Peter Norvig's New Book

#24

Post by bxtt »

This book should be geared for one of those introduction courses, like “Introduction to Engineering”, “AI 101”, etc. I do agree with the vision of the authors that the book is a holistic view of data science, as I personally believe data science is not all about maths, programming; but consider the principles that surround it as a science.

This is also quite practical for large consultancy firms. Most of the chapters, I’ve had clients discuss with me (such as Responsible AI). Personally, I think it could have went away from the applications as it was too high level.

Re: Data Science in Context – Peter Norvig's New Book

#26

Post by robertlagrant »

urthor wrote: post #23
wrp wrote: post #19

They should change the title. It is not a book for programmers about implementation of data science techniques. It is a book for managers about concerns surrounding the application of data science in various domains. The title should be something like "Social Concerns in the Application of Data Science."

It's a book for data scientists. Data scientists are not software engineers. They analyze data, they don't produce applications. Not everything in the world is written for the benefit of software engineers.

Previous poster didn't mention software engineers.

Re: Data Science in Context – Peter Norvig's New Book

#28

Post by wrp »

urthor wrote: post #23
wrp wrote: post #19

They should change the title. It is not a book for programmers about implementation of data science techniques. It is a book for managers about concerns surrounding the application of data science in various domains. The title should be something like "Social Concerns in the Application of Data Science."

It's a book for data scientists. Data scientists are not software engineers. They analyze data, they don't produce applications. Not everything in the world is written for the benefit of software engineers.

While data science is not principally about programming, I think that having Norvig as one of the authors will lead to false expectations of the book unless the title is made more informative.
Post reply on HN