Earlier quoted context omitted.
Yes, I am a researcher and a Ph.D. student in the field of nuclear reactor physics. I regularly operate and do experiments on a research nuclear reactor. My name is in my hn username and I have no problem defending my claims. I also own a popular TikTok account where I do science communication about nuclear reactors. My information about the water discharge comes from reports by IAEA, who is the authority on the matt…
Out of curiosity, why do you write 'Thritium' for 'Tritium'?
Japan’s plan to dump nuclear waste into the pacific ocean may not be safe
21–30 of 184 posts
Re: Japan’s plan to dump nuclear waste into the pacific ocean may not be safe
#22The Japanese have lots of credits on environmental issues: it's one of the cleanest country I've ever seen, so I'm willing to trust them if they say the waste water dumping plan is safe.
Edit: Hey, look, somebody wrote a book with the latin thing I said as its title, whose contents I probably summarized the thesis of without even reading.
https://www.amazon.com/PAX-JAPONICA-Resurrection-Takeo-Harad...
Re: Japan’s plan to dump nuclear waste into the pacific ocean may not be safe
#23Re: Japan’s plan to dump nuclear waste into the pacific ocean may not be safe
#24Why not dropping that to the Sahara or to any remote desert that nobody lives?
They are dumping 1 Million metric tons of water over a period of 30 years. Even if China allow them to dump the water into the Gobi desert, it'd still cost billions of dollar to build and operate the pipeline. It'd never happen.
Re: Japan’s plan to dump nuclear waste into the pacific ocean may not be safe
#25The Japanese have lots of credits on environmental issues: it's one of the cleanest country I've ever seen, so I'm willing to trust them if they say the waste water dumping plan is safe.
We're relying on mostly the same people, minus the pragmatic ones who went to bluer skies, to now make trade-offs related to how much Japan's willing to pollute the surrounding seas relative to the economic and politic situation.
Re: Japan’s plan to dump nuclear waste into the pacific ocean may not be safe
#26Re: Japan’s plan to dump nuclear waste into the pacific ocean may not be safe
#27Tritium is already present in the ocean naturally and we are not talking about Nuclear Waste, as the title suggests, but clean water. We also cannot compare the tritium with mercury, because tritium, even if released in the ocean, decays away. Mecury, on the other hand, stays forever. The concerns that the water will affect marine life might be well intended but will cause more harm than good. In the worst possible c…
Exactly. And if the quantities Japan are talking about are correct (860 TBq / trillion becquerels), this is a huge fuss about nothing. France's La Hague nuclear reprocessing facility discharges many times more tritium than that into the English Channel every single year as part of it's normal operations!
Re: Japan’s plan to dump nuclear waste into the pacific ocean may not be safe
#28Tritium is already present in the ocean naturally and we are not talking about Nuclear Waste, as the title suggests, but clean water. We also cannot compare the tritium with mercury, because tritium, even if released in the ocean, decays away. Mecury, on the other hand, stays forever. The concerns that the water will affect marine life might be well intended but will cause more harm than good. In the worst possible c…
Right, it’s all safe and fine as long as we don’t release the water into your own backyard and swimming pool.
Re: Japan’s plan to dump nuclear waste into the pacific ocean may not be safe
#29Earlier quoted context omitted.
They are dumping 1 Million metric tons of water over a period of 30 years. Even if China allow them to dump the water into the Gobi desert, it'd still cost billions of dollar to build and operate the pipeline. It'd never happen.
True but at this point it's not just a Japanese problem but a world wide one, if they dump it in the ocean, it could affect all the life that live there and consequently human life that feeds of it. It reminds me of the WW2 boats that are still in the Oceans leaking toxic products and nobody wants to pay to take them out.
Re: Japan’s plan to dump nuclear waste into the pacific ocean may not be safe
#30WasteWATER*. I hate when titles leave important things out to make them sound worse than they are. This is about WATER waste.