Live data from Hacker News

Guido van Rossum: Let Web3 die in a flaming ball of fire

twitter.com

21–30 of 316 posts

Re: Guido van Rossum: Let Web3 die in a flaming ball of fire

#21
post #9

The interesting thing about crypto to me is how there seems to be a deep divide among very smart people, some who think it's the greatest thing ever and some who think it's a fraud. I can't remember when there's ever been such a Bigendian-scale dispute in technology before. Can you?

How many of those smart people have vested interests in the crypto market or the Web 3.0 rebranding?

Re: Guido van Rossum: Let Web3 die in a flaming ball of fire

#22
post #9

The interesting thing about crypto to me is how there seems to be a deep divide among very smart people, some who think it's the greatest thing ever and some who think it's a fraud. I can't remember when there's ever been such a Bigendian-scale dispute in technology before. Can you?

How many of these "very smart" people were just early adopters of cryptocurrencies? Usually there is a financial conflict of interest which causes people to overlook the extremely negative aspects of web3/cryptocurrencies. Anecdotally I have seen a lot of people who were previously gung-ho cash out and sour on the whole space.

Re: Guido van Rossum: Let Web3 die in a flaming ball of fire

#23
post #9

The interesting thing about crypto to me is how there seems to be a deep divide among very smart people, some who think it's the greatest thing ever and some who think it's a fraud. I can't remember when there's ever been such a Bigendian-scale dispute in technology before. Can you?

if you define "smart" as rich, then your comment makes sense i guess.

Re: Guido van Rossum: Let Web3 die in a flaming ball of fire

#24
post #12
post #9

The interesting thing about crypto to me is how there seems to be a deep divide among very smart people, some who think it's the greatest thing ever and some who think it's a fraud. I can't remember when there's ever been such a Bigendian-scale dispute in technology before. Can you?

Where is the divide? Crypto is 99% full of hucksters, and the remaining 1% are the sorry saps. The intelligent people I know want nothing to do with it. Folks I've met IRL who are into it usually aren't all that bright. The traits they do have are affinity for risk taking, and being somewhat technical but not too much so, just enough to be dangerous. They certainly won't be opening any PRs to fix Ethereum bugs. In ot…

There is a real cohort of libertarian folks who really do want digital anonymous cash replacement.

Re: Guido van Rossum: Let Web3 die in a flaming ball of fire

#26
post #9

The interesting thing about crypto to me is how there seems to be a deep divide among very smart people, some who think it's the greatest thing ever and some who think it's a fraud. I can't remember when there's ever been such a Bigendian-scale dispute in technology before. Can you?

[deleted]

Re: Guido van Rossum: Let Web3 die in a flaming ball of fire

#28
post #3

My question is why Y Combinator funded anything related to web3 and why it seems to defend these ideas when they are attacked on HN.

No one can say for sure how the entire thing is going to turn out. As investors, there's no harm in placing multiple bets as long as a small number of those bets end up giving an outsized return.

Re: Guido van Rossum: Let Web3 die in a flaming ball of fire

#29
post #24
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Where is the divide? Crypto is 99% full of hucksters, and the remaining 1% are the sorry saps. The intelligent people I know want nothing to do with it. Folks I've met IRL who are into it usually aren't all that bright. The traits they do have are affinity for risk taking, and being somewhat technical but not too much so, just enough to be dangerous. They certainly won't be opening any PRs to fix Ethereum bugs. In ot…

There is a real cohort of libertarian folks who really do want digital anonymous cash replacement.

Cryptocurrency is not that, because it is not anonymous nor is it a cash replacement. I have sympathy for those folks who were led to believe those things, it's not their fault.

Re: Guido van Rossum: Let Web3 die in a flaming ball of fire

#30
post #4

For those who don't know web3 is the idea of building a web on a decentralized blockchain. I think more specifically the idea is to replace the need for name servers with a blockchain protocol. Like anything blockchain there is no real solution for how to handle records becoming stale over time without a central authority that manages disputes. I find it ridiculous that this idea even got to occupy the name as I thin…

I don't think that's what web3 is, that's just one direction some are taking it. Web3 is a move away from centralized platforms to ones which are either decentralized or more directly controlled by users (self-hosted, federated). > Like anything blockchain there is no real solution for how to handle records becoming stale over time without a central authority that manages disputes. I don't understand this part. In pr…

We can have self-hosted, federated web sites with Web 1.0 technology.
Post reply on HN