Live data from Hacker News

Bunny DNS – A scriptable DNS platform

bunny.net

21–30 of 90 posts

Re: Bunny DNS – A scriptable DNS platform

#21
post #2

It always puzzles me when people speak of "routing" in conjunction with DNS.

Makes me question what else they are incompetent in.

A company i work with uses their cdn product. We have been using them for a year or so now, with no issues, and a very helpful support team.

They are fairly competent and cheap. A happy bunny customer here

Re: Bunny DNS – A scriptable DNS platform

#23
This is very clever, and something I wished existed inside of AWS/Route53. It would greatly simplify some of the work needed for redundancy/resilience. Something similar as a locally-deployable "unbound/dnsmasq style" component would be neat as well.

Re: Bunny DNS – A scriptable DNS platform

#26
post #7

Like the idea. But… 1) Claim privacy first and then have a cookie banner. 2) Say “routing” when you mean location/IP based DNS. 3) Is that a loosely typed language in the scripting engine? Not sure I would want DNS queries to be relying on that. I am sure there is still some innovation left in DNS. SDDNS I’d call it: Software defined DNS. Especially with the splinternet we are walking into these days. Just don’t thin…

Cookies as tech say nothing about privacy. If you want to store information that you refuse to share your private data - that almost certainly is getting stored in a cookie. You can route connections on different layers than IP routing. We commonly talk about http request routing as in dispatch based on the domain/path. I'm happy with "routing" as in directing traffic via DNS resolution. I doubt anyone here is confus…

> I'm happy with "routing" as in directing traffic via DNS resolution. I doubt anyone here is confusing that.

I disagree. As a former network engineer the title "We're transforming internet routing" and subtitle "Rethinking Internet Routing" [my emphasis] makes me think of IP based routing first. I think they could have been clearer or picked a less grandiose title.

Don't get me wrong, on the surface this looks like a neat tool.

Re: Bunny DNS – A scriptable DNS platform

#27
post #12
post #2

It always puzzles me when people speak of "routing" in conjunction with DNS.

People also speak of routing with respect to web applications and woodworking.

Sure, most of us understand there are different uses of the word "routing" with respect to technology stacks. But they specifically say "Internet Routing" in the article title and elsewhere. "Internet Routing" does have a fairly specific meaning i.e. IP routing as define by a bunch of RFC's. What they're doing isn't really "internet routing", it's really just redirecting traffic.

Re: Bunny DNS – A scriptable DNS platform

#28

Does location-based DNS even have a future? fly.io doesn't seem to think so: https://fly.io/blog/the-5-hour-content-delivery-network/

Probably, but there are competing priorities:

1. Location based DNS is incredibly useful

2. Sending user data (IP address, location) to authoritative nameservers is out of vogue.

There are efforts to send privacy-friendly geo info to authoritative nameservers. But they aren't getting much traction. Which means location based DNS is getting less useful by the day (because it's not working for as many people).

Re: Bunny DNS – A scriptable DNS platform

#29

there is so much wrong with this site i thought it was april 1st. i thought it's been proven that geo-ip data is not reliable? second.. DNS is not routing.

Now I'm curious. Do you have a link for the geo-ip unreliability by any chance?

geo-ip has never returned the correct state for me (across 3 different ISPs). The automatic Timezone detection on phones also rarely works correctly here.

So I can easily believe that it’s wildly inaccurate for a significant amount of the world.

Post reply on HN