Live data from Hacker News

Why am I seeing this adorable red panda?

mozilla.org

21–30 of 49 posts

Re: Why am I seeing this adorable red panda?

#21

On the one hand Mozilla needs to make money somehow, on the other hand, this does feel tacky. What other alternative is there that would actually be sustainable for them?

I'm always a fan of the donation drive. I'd take a tab pop-up of https://donate.mozilla.org/en-US/ over an occasional ad like this one any day.

I'd love to do a shameless plug for radioparadise.com as a wonderful model of someone who does an extremely tasteful periodic reminder to donate :).

Re: Why am I seeing this adorable red panda?

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Interesting. Yes; it is a slimy bait-and-switch ad for Disney's newest animated series - ultimately an ad for their streaming service. I will not support them by posting links here.

Every day I consider saying 'to hell with it' and going back to Safari.

Safari does not seem to have a robust adblocker solution. I could be mistaken but it seems like you can only install extensions through their app store? So convoluted compared to Chrome. It is blazing fast though. :/

Re: Why am I seeing this adorable red panda?

#23
post #4

I put enormous effort into blocking as much advertising and marketing from my life as is humanly possible. I have written my own browser plugins and scripts, I have created network-wide blockers, I do not listen to the radio, I do not watch television, I do not look at billboards. I use Firefox to protect my privacy from advertisers and to block ads. So you may be able to imaging my rage when Firefox updated and auto…

I (based in Europe) see a page presenting Mozilla VPN. Are you saying you see an ad for Disney? [edit] I used a United States VPN now. Indeed a Disney ad for a movie. In Europe it's a static page with some text about Mozilla VPN.

Even the page with Mozilla VPN is an ad, although first-party and not third party.

Re: Why am I seeing this adorable red panda?

#24

On the one hand Mozilla needs to make money somehow, on the other hand, this does feel tacky. What other alternative is there that would actually be sustainable for them?

Does Greenpeace need to "make money"?

Mozilla is a nonprofit. They need income obviously but it feels like they are taking a very different approach than most nonprofits.

Re: Why am I seeing this adorable red panda?

#26

This is just shown once after a browser upgrade right? And not even baked into the browser? And for a first party product? Are we really complaining about something as little invasive as that?

> And for a first party product?

This seems to depend on what country you load it from. This web archive link shows you what we get in the US.

https://web.archive.org/web/20220308222503/https://www.mozil...

Re: Why am I seeing this adorable red panda?

#27
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes. It’s obnoxious, shabby, and needs to be shut down—swift and hard—before Mozilla gets the idea that turning its browser into a billboard is an acceptable method of making money. Because believe me, if this kind of thing turns out to be profitable for them, that garbage will not be limited to a mere static image shown just once. Given Mozilla’s current financial problems, and who their core users tend to be, this…

It is important to keep Firefox solvent and operational as it is the last real independent browser. Everything else is built on Chromium (or Webkit), which are owned and spied upon by Google (and Apple?)

Independent of what? The ad-o-sphere? If they are showing ads, they are not independent of them.

Re: Why am I seeing this adorable red panda?

#28
The submitted title ("Mozilla Now Hitting Us with Full Page Ads") broke the site guideline against editorializing.

"Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize." - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

If you want to say what you think is important about an article, that's fine, but do it by adding a comment to the thread. Then your view will be on a level playing field with everyone else's: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...

Re: Why am I seeing this adorable red panda?

#30

I put enormous effort into blocking as much advertising and marketing from my life as is humanly possible. I have written my own browser plugins and scripts, I have created network-wide blockers, I do not listen to the radio, I do not watch television, I do not look at billboards. I use Firefox to protect my privacy from advertisers and to block ads. So you may be able to imaging my rage when Firefox updated and auto…

To answer my own question: there is a Google Tag Manager at least, along with Mozilla's own telemetry and Sentry.
Post reply on HN