Live data from Hacker News

Huawei MatePad Paper – eInk Tablet

consumer.huawei.com

21–30 of 332 posts

Re: Huawei MatePad Paper – eInk Tablet

#21

Phenomenal news. I’m hoping competition drives prices down. Remarkable 2 looks neat but so expensive. Now there’s choice.

It all comes down to the paper like writing feel + latency. Several contenders have been compared to RM2, but RM2 has consistently won out. Curious how this one does.

Re: Huawei MatePad Paper – eInk Tablet

#22
post #3

RRP €499 (around $558) according to https://www.theverge.com/2022/2/28/22954498/huawei-matepad-p...

Hm, is that really a competitive price these days? That's more than 130 Euros more than an entry-level iPad... which has a long and good track record.

It's not the same thing. I think the target use cases are different. The e-ink and pen input combination is really trying to create a paper-like experience (which's great for reading and taking notes).

On the other hand iPad is more general-purpose powerhouse for pretty much anything, but if I'm between this and iPad for reading some books I'd prefer this. And I use/love an iPad Pro+Apple Pencil. Still would consider this for my long book/blog/paper reads.

Re: Huawei MatePad Paper – eInk Tablet

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most of the expense on these e-ink tablets comes from the huge cost of that screen, so unless Huawei is willing to subsidize this product and monetize your private data instead, I doubt this will be significantly cheaper than the competition. Regardless of price though, I'm not willing to out my private data on Huawei devices.

not to sound cynical but you are willing to draw the line with an american company, say google but not an openly chinese company like huawei. cool. what about all the chinese people then? why would they want to use a google device over a huawei device? shouldnt the discussion be about no company being able to harvest data in the first place, then we wouldnt be having this discussion about nationalities of the overlor…

You're making a lot of claims about me and about Chinese people, which are not true, based on stuff you made up.

Re: Huawei MatePad Paper – eInk Tablet

#24
post #12

Will it have a browser? It would be great for reading HN, coding, writing if I could use it with a browser. I do all these in the browser and I only need black and white and no fancy tools. So even if the browser is much slower than on a desktop, it would still be great.

People usually recommend the "Boox" devices for that.

As they are running on Android you can therefore, after activating it, access the Play Store to get a browser running...

Maybe that's the way to go.

Re: Huawei MatePad Paper – eInk Tablet

#25
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Remarkable 2 looks neat but so expensive . Now there’s choice. R2 is $399, judging from the EUR retail price of €499 inc. VAT this will likely retail at $499 in US. It is not cheaper than R2.

The prices reMarkable advertise are deceptive to the point where I reckon they’re probably illegal under at least Australian advertising law: that price doesn’t include a marker, which is almost essential to the deliberately expressed purpose of the device; so add on another 20%. Most people will also want some kind of cover, which is another 20% for the cheapest reMarkable sells. You’ve got to be careful about this…

Also, if you want basic features like cloud sync and handwriting conversion, you have to sign up for the $8/mo subscription.

Which is why hell will freeze over before I purchase a reMarkable.

Incidentally, the free plan offers something called "50-day sync", which is described like this:

"Without a subscription, you can still use the cloud to store and sync your notes. However, files will stop syncing to the mobile and desktop apps if they haven’t been opened in the last 50 days. They’ll still be automatically stored on your paper tablet."

Just to be clear: This is a feature designed for the marketing department, not for users.

The marketing people get to say that "we offer free cloud sync", while reducing users' trust in the cloud sync significantly enough that they feel obliged to sign up for the paid subscription.

It's infuriating.

Re: Huawei MatePad Paper – eInk Tablet

#26
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Remarkable 2 looks neat but so expensive . Now there’s choice. R2 is $399, judging from the EUR retail price of €499 inc. VAT this will likely retail at $499 in US. It is not cheaper than R2.

The prices reMarkable advertise are deceptive to the point where I reckon they’re probably illegal under at least Australian advertising law: that price doesn’t include a marker, which is almost essential to the deliberately expressed purpose of the device; so add on another 20%. Most people will also want some kind of cover, which is another 20% for the cheapest reMarkable sells. You’ve got to be careful about this…

You can use any standard resistive stylus pen though, which you can get for extremely cheap anywhere (and you need to anyway, since the tips will wear down). The only thing their accessory pen adds is a built-in eraser.

Re: Huawei MatePad Paper – eInk Tablet

#27
post #12

Will it have a browser? It would be great for reading HN, coding, writing if I could use it with a browser. I do all these in the browser and I only need black and white and no fancy tools. So even if the browser is much slower than on a desktop, it would still be great.

People usually recommend the "Boox" devices for that. As they are running on Android you can therefore, after activating it, access the Play Store to get a browser running... Maybe that's the way to go.

You don't even need to activate the Play Store. They include a browser out of the box.

Re: Huawei MatePad Paper – eInk Tablet

#28
post #3

RRP €499 (around $558) according to https://www.theverge.com/2022/2/28/22954498/huawei-matepad-p...

Hm, is that really a competitive price these days? That's more than 130 Euros more than an entry-level iPad... which has a long and good track record.

The Matepad seems expensive though is comparable to other large eInk readers, but the iPad certainly doesn't have a track record as a dedicated (eInk) e-reader. Two very different things here.

Re: Huawei MatePad Paper – eInk Tablet

#29
post #12

Will it have a browser? It would be great for reading HN, coding, writing if I could use it with a browser. I do all these in the browser and I only need black and white and no fancy tools. So even if the browser is much slower than on a desktop, it would still be great.

People usually recommend the "Boox" devices for that. As they are running on Android you can therefore, after activating it, access the Play Store to get a browser running... Maybe that's the way to go.

Second the Boox; unfortunately there are gpl violations which is a shame, but I got an A4 sized one before I knew that and I use Pocket to read online stuff offline and use the built in reader to read books and work on papers (the dual note/read view is lovely).

Re: Huawei MatePad Paper – eInk Tablet

#30
post #3

RRP €499 (around $558) according to https://www.theverge.com/2022/2/28/22954498/huawei-matepad-p...

Hm, is that really a competitive price these days? That's more than 130 Euros more than an entry-level iPad... which has a long and good track record.

Similar price and specs to the PineNote.
Post reply on HN