Live data from Hacker News

Radar fall detection and breath rate under $40

seeedstudio.com

21–30 of 59 posts

Re: Radar fall detection and breath rate under $40

#21
So I love Seeedstudio and their innovative and affordable hardware. I bought quite a lot over the past years and always been quite happy for the quality.

However, they blame the chip shortage for their own inability to manage their inventory.

I've had to cancel my last order (all items in stock and paid for at the time). I contacted them after a few weeks seeing the items were not yet shipped. They replied that some items were out of stock. I agreed to remove them. A couple of days later, they reply again that more items (similar sensor as the one featured here) are no longer in stock....

This tells me that that their website isn't showing the actual stock status at the time of order, that their system doesn't reserve quantities for items already purchased, and that they don't really communicate unless you chase them (but they respond quickly).

If you purchase anything, have a follow-up ticket within 3 days to make sure they take care of your order and quickly assert whether all parts are available.

I like Seedstudio but they need to sort out their logistics and inventory management. My previous order took 4 months to ship and had multiple shortages and delays as well.

Re: Radar fall detection and breath rate under $40

#22

The breath rate application really got my mind turning here— replacing 2 wearables (breath monitor, fall monitor) with a wireless device, and pulse sensing can already be done by video. Imagine walking into a hospital room or grandma’s home & having full bio monitoring with no tubes or cables…

Does this product/service currently exist as bundle, an easily connected assortment of services, or something that needs to be created? If so, I love to know how I can help make this a reality!

Re: Radar fall detection and breath rate under $40

#23

The breath rate application really got my mind turning here— replacing 2 wearables (breath monitor, fall monitor) with a wireless device, and pulse sensing can already be done by video. Imagine walking into a hospital room or grandma’s home & having full bio monitoring with no tubes or cables…

In 2014, the ResMed office in Ireland was doing this “off label” with their S+ sleep monitor. They were very close, and the goal/target market was for seniors in long term care facilities.

Their current website states "S+ is coming to an end. Support from ResMed for the S+ sleep tracking device and app is coming to an end. We have collaborated with SleepScore Labs™ so you can continue tracking your sleep through their SleepScore Max mobile app only with your prior consent. Learn more here.. If you wish to have your account and personal data deleted, please contact us at customerservice@mySplus.com"

http://sleep.mysplus.com/

The product looks to be available currently on Amazon in the US: https://www.amazon.com/ResMed-S-Personal-Sleep-Solution/dp/B...

Are there a superior competing product(s) now? Why was support for this product discontinued?

Re: Radar fall detection and breath rate under $40

#24

The breath rate application really got my mind turning here— replacing 2 wearables (breath monitor, fall monitor) with a wireless device, and pulse sensing can already be done by video. Imagine walking into a hospital room or grandma’s home & having full bio monitoring with no tubes or cables…

Does this product/service currently exist as bundle, an easily connected assortment of services, or something that needs to be created? If so, I love to know how I can help make this a reality!

The sleep number smart beds detect heart and breath rate through the bed's pressure sensor.

Re: Radar fall detection and breath rate under $40

#26

The breath rate application really got my mind turning here— replacing 2 wearables (breath monitor, fall monitor) with a wireless device, and pulse sensing can already be done by video. Imagine walking into a hospital room or grandma’s home & having full bio monitoring with no tubes or cables…

Imagine embedding this in my childs bassinet.

Re: Radar fall detection and breath rate under $40

#27
post #11

When my late father moved into the nursing home they stuck him in the basement which had long hallways and at the time was mostly vacant. He had a walker and it didn't dawn on us it would ever be a problem. But then he had a fall and couldn't get up. Anywhere else in the facility a staff member would have found him within five minutes. After a half hour and multiple failed attempts to stand he remembered his cell pho…

It's sad but most facilities are like this. If you want your elderly parents to have assistance, either move them in with you or hire private help and verify that they are doing what you want. Nursing homes and care facilities mainly exist to drain the assets of the elderly and then get them on medicaid until they die.

Re: Radar fall detection and breath rate under $40

#28
> With the enhanced Infineon Doppler radar and the standard algorithm, the module is an ideal solution for individual applications like elderly health care, smart home, and danger alarm.

Anybody know what they mean by "the standard algorithm" for fall detection?

Re: Radar fall detection and breath rate under $40

#29
post #15
post #11

When my late father moved into the nursing home they stuck him in the basement which had long hallways and at the time was mostly vacant. He had a walker and it didn't dawn on us it would ever be a problem. But then he had a fall and couldn't get up. Anywhere else in the facility a staff member would have found him within five minutes. After a half hour and multiple failed attempts to stand he remembered his cell pho…

> A device like this could have alerted someone at the facility that he had fallen, this is a very big deal and it's going to save lives. Nope. It will never get deployed. The problem is that when it fails, who is liable? I've said it over and over, but the revolution in biomedical will happen when someone solves the problem of indemnity and not before.

No post body was provided.

Re: Radar fall detection and breath rate under $40

#30
WiFi can be used to monitor heart rate, falls and other human activity, through your (and neighbor) walls, https://www.theverge.com/2022/1/3/22864783/sengled-smart-hea...

DFWS (Device-Free Wireless Sensing) is possible with low-cost ESP32 devices and custom firmware, https://academic.oup.com/jcde/article/7/5/644/5837600

802.11bf WiFi Sensing is scheduled to be part of WiFi 7 in 2024, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29901587

Post reply on HN