Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: View the patent and innovation history of any company

goodip.io

21–30 of 37 posts

Re: Show HN: View the patent and innovation history of any company

#21
post #3

I checked a number of companies that I know that have IP and patents and they came out empty. Maybe it is only accurate for public companies? Or maybe just partially accurate? This seems to be more of a partial source and not a definitive resource.

Hi 1cvmask, we included assignees with more than 20 patents only. Could you give me some examples so that I can investigate?

Re: Show HN: View the patent and innovation history of any company

#22
post #4

Cool! My first search ("bosch") turned up almost a quarter of a million in the main company. Waay more than e.g. Ericsson, Milwaukee, Ryobi, Microsoft and Google which I searched next. Is there a "leaderboard" page? Edit: found the top lists at the bottom, but I don't want to pick a category, and the list format shows list position but not patent count unless you click each entry, which to me was not very accessible.

Hi unwind, thanks for the feedback. We do actually have leadership pages per industry, technology and patent office. E.g. https://goodip.io/iq/top/technologies or https://goodip.io/iq/top/industries. Cleantech innovation categories are going to follow soon.

Re: Show HN: View the patent and innovation history of any company

#24

FYI: The formatting/rendering of this page is way off for me (Chrome on 16" Mac). The top of the page is missing, and the bottom is cut off and doesn't scroll. Need to look at your UI again.

Hi woodgrainz. Thanks a lot for the feedback, we are about to fix this issue.

Re: Show HN: View the patent and innovation history of any company

#25

There's an issue with data concordance (I think that's the term) in that, for example, Snekma is listed as having a few RU patents but that's actually the same company as SNECMA (French aeronautical company) which is listed as having many more patents; but that company is now known as Safran. A proper historical analysis of companies would need to account for mergers/splits/renames of companies themselves - data whic…

Hi pbhjpbhj, thanks for the feedback. I think at the moment company name disambiguation, especially with patents is an unsolved problem. There are easier tasks such as cleaning typos and company name changes, but then as you mentioned - mergers, splits etc. Which companies with exactly the same name but in different countries are the same? And in most cases ownership changes of the patents are not even tracked. Thats why we decided to do some preprocessing, but did not try to solve this problem by now.

Re: Show HN: View the patent and innovation history of any company

#26

Holy crap this is powerful. Is the company simlarity done using a clustering measurement on the corpus of language in the patents? I can't think of a product manager whose job does will not depend on this.

Hi motohagiography, thanks a lot for the kind feedback, much appreciated. I built profiles for each company based on their filing strategy and technology and then in a second step computed their similarity using Pearson. If you are interested in the details, I put together some of the details here https://medium.com/goodip/ding-the-pearson-correlation-matri... Cheers Linus

Re: Show HN: View the patent and innovation history of any company

#28
post #6
post #4

Cool! My first search ("bosch") turned up almost a quarter of a million in the main company. Waay more than e.g. Ericsson, Milwaukee, Ryobi, Microsoft and Google which I searched next. Is there a "leaderboard" page? Edit: found the top lists at the bottom, but I don't want to pick a category, and the list format shows list position but not patent count unless you click each entry, which to me was not very accessible.

Indeed, leaderboard per jurisdiction would be super interesting. IBM with 287000 patents would likely be in the top ones.

We have a leaderboard per country. IBM is indeed No.1 for the US: https://goodip.io/iq/top/offices/us

The all-time leaderboards for each industry and each technology are here: https://goodip.io/iq/top/industries https://goodip.io/iq/top/technologies

Re: Show HN: View the patent and innovation history of any company

#29

Microsoft seems to hold something over 100,000 worldwide (their main company and through their licensing company). Is there any logic in limiting the number of patents a company can hold? at what point do you simply have too many? is there such a thing as a monopoly from a purely intellectual property perspective?. Just thinking out loud.

Hi have_faith, Great question! That's one of the reasons we built GoodIP IQ: It can give everyone insights into the secret patent universe. And you are correct: Does it really make sense to have so many patents? How can startups deal with 100,000 patents just at Microsoft?

Re: Show HN: View the patent and innovation history of any company

#30

Microsoft seems to hold something over 100,000 worldwide (their main company and through their licensing company). Is there any logic in limiting the number of patents a company can hold? at what point do you simply have too many? is there such a thing as a monopoly from a purely intellectual property perspective?. Just thinking out loud.

Some are defensive some are offensive. Someone like Qualcomm uses them to get a percentage of every device but also uses them to protect themselves against other companies, as they also sell chipsets. Also patents expire. So they may have one but after the time limit they are not really worth much anymore other than a defense. Would limiting the number they hold really help? Think one chipset they had to pull was ove…

Good point, sumtechguy! I agree limiting numbers might not really help. However, giving startups the tools to understand the patent game might help a lot. What do you think?
Post reply on HN