Live data from Hacker News

Countering climate change with cool pavements

news.mit.edu

21–30 of 80 posts

Re: Countering climate change with cool pavements

#21
post #3

> “Conversely, by reflecting light — called incident radiation — onto nearby buildings, cool pavements can warm structures up, which can increase AC usage in the summer and lower heating demand in the winter.” this is one of the reasons why i'm an advocate for street trees, and urban foliage in general (cuts down both incident and reflective radiation), and why i'm maddened when i see urban trees cut down or cut back…

While I initially would prefer the idea of more street trees the nagging voice in the back of my head continues to worry about unintended consequences. A big one regarding more trees is more maintenance, you've already pointed out how terrible maintenance can be, and lawns alone are an incredible example of just how inefficient we handle plants in the name of some arbitrary aesthetic, tons of water wasted, many hours…

One logical answer is "Artificial trees".

That is, constructed shade structures that provides shade without being unpredictable living things.

There are probably real problems with that approach too. What are they?

Re: Countering climate change with cool pavements

#23
post #6

This totally nerd-sniped[0] me, and now I'm going down the rabbit hole wondering if there's a business opportunity for generating electricity via the thermoelectric effect[1] and thus literally cooling the pavement by pulling some energy out and putting it to good use. [0] https://xkcd.com/356/ [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermoelectric_generator

>[0] https://xkcd.com/356/

Because of the hat, I like to think the two characters are Heisenberg and Pinkman.

Re: Countering climate change with cool pavements

#25
post #3

> “Conversely, by reflecting light — called incident radiation — onto nearby buildings, cool pavements can warm structures up, which can increase AC usage in the summer and lower heating demand in the winter.” this is one of the reasons why i'm an advocate for street trees, and urban foliage in general (cuts down both incident and reflective radiation), and why i'm maddened when i see urban trees cut down or cut back…

from one LA resident to another, amen to that. we were just walking down our street this morning and discussing, for the umpteenth time, whether our neighbors would actually be willing to take care of trees if we went out and bought them and planted them. the problem, as other commenters have pointed out, is that they do require upkeep, but since they're living/breathing things the more hardy ones can really be abuse…

LA has an woefully underpublicized street (and lawn) tree program, where you can get free trees if you agree to take care of them (which is mostly just periodic watering), so you wouldn't even have to buy them yourself. for street trees on the parkway (the patch of ground between the sidewalk and street), you don't technically even need the permission of the owner, although the owner might not be amenable to watering them then. apartment dwellers (like me) can get trees planted on the parkway just by agreeing to take care of them on behalf of the owner.

Re: Countering climate change with cool pavements

#26
post #3

> “Conversely, by reflecting light — called incident radiation — onto nearby buildings, cool pavements can warm structures up, which can increase AC usage in the summer and lower heating demand in the winter.” this is one of the reasons why i'm an advocate for street trees, and urban foliage in general (cuts down both incident and reflective radiation), and why i'm maddened when i see urban trees cut down or cut back…

While I generally agree, you also have to be careful not to go too far in the other direction. My cousin's car was totaled while driving in Philadelphia. A large tree, that was not actively maintained, fell over when the ground was too wet. A foot difference and he would have been killed.

Re: Countering climate change with cool pavements

#27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

While I initially would prefer the idea of more street trees the nagging voice in the back of my head continues to worry about unintended consequences. A big one regarding more trees is more maintenance, you've already pointed out how terrible maintenance can be, and lawns alone are an incredible example of just how inefficient we handle plants in the name of some arbitrary aesthetic, tons of water wasted, many hours…

One logical answer is "Artificial trees". That is, constructed shade structures that provides shade without being unpredictable living things. There are probably real problems with that approach too. What are they?

mainly cost. trees are cheap (~$100-300) compared to tarps or other fixed shade options, though i'm down for any and all shade. for comparison, bus shelters are estimated to cost $5K-30K each ( https://pedestrianobservations.com/2019/04/12/little-things-... ).

Re: Countering climate change with cool pavements

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

While I initially would prefer the idea of more street trees the nagging voice in the back of my head continues to worry about unintended consequences. A big one regarding more trees is more maintenance, you've already pointed out how terrible maintenance can be, and lawns alone are an incredible example of just how inefficient we handle plants in the name of some arbitrary aesthetic, tons of water wasted, many hours…

One logical answer is "Artificial trees". That is, constructed shade structures that provides shade without being unpredictable living things. There are probably real problems with that approach too. What are they?

Artificial plants are like synthetic plastic grave stones, superior in almost every way to the traditional approach yet considered incredibly tacky.

Re: Countering climate change with cool pavements

#29
post #6

This totally nerd-sniped[0] me, and now I'm going down the rabbit hole wondering if there's a business opportunity for generating electricity via the thermoelectric effect[1] and thus literally cooling the pavement by pulling some energy out and putting it to good use. [0] https://xkcd.com/356/ [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermoelectric_generator

I’ll save you some time: absolutely not.

Why so certain?
Post reply on HN