Live data from Hacker News

The best books on assassinations

fivebooks.com

21–30 of 37 posts

Re: The best books on assassinations

#21

> "Hitler, uncharacteristically, cut short the speech he was making to go and plan the invasion of France. Had he continued speaking, he would have been blown to pieces in November 1939. That would have surely have been a very good thing because, in the period between that event and the June 1944 bomb plot, two-and-a-half million German soldiers died." Ah yes, the group of people who were famously killed en masse bec…

WTF. I agree with sister comment from GordonS. But also need to say, that the numbers are off. WW II cost significantly less than 6 million German soldiers' lifes. The author states that 7 million German soldiers died. But yeah. Stating the death of German soldiers as the most important outcome from WW II is imho at least problematic. It shows a lack of empathy and historic sensitivity.

> Stating the death of German soldiers as the most important outcome from WW II

Who stated that?

The quote explicitly relates to Elser, whose motive in Hitler's assassination was to save Germany's workers and common people from war.

So mentioning the losses of German "cannon fodder" seems appropriate. Common Germans are what Elser cared about (and failed to save). I see no evil motive or lack of empathy on author's part.

Re: The best books on assassinations

#22

> "Hitler, uncharacteristically, cut short the speech he was making to go and plan the invasion of France. Had he continued speaking, he would have been blown to pieces in November 1939. That would have surely have been a very good thing because, in the period between that event and the June 1944 bomb plot, two-and-a-half million German soldiers died." Ah yes, the group of people who were famously killed en masse bec…

WTF. I agree with sister comment from GordonS. But also need to say, that the numbers are off. WW II cost significantly less than 6 million German soldiers' lifes. The author states that 7 million German soldiers died. But yeah. Stating the death of German soldiers as the most important outcome from WW II is imho at least problematic. It shows a lack of empathy and historic sensitivity.

> Stating the death of German soldiers as the most important outcome from WW II is imho at least problematic

Who is stating that? I don't see it there.

Re: The best books on assassinations

#25
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Everybody kills Hitler on their first (time) trip. https://archive.briankoberlein.com/2015/11/09/everybody-kill...

And then you're left with and even bigger jerk that rose in the ranks in his absence! MechaHitler

see “Making History” by Stephen Fry

Re: The best books on assassinations

#26

This is a bit off-topic, but Navalny calling his killer and pranking him into telling all kinds of nasty details of Navalny's own killing attempt is mind-bogging [1]. I am sure this is now part of all secrets services of the world 101 trainings. Full audio with English transcript: [2]. There is also a bit of background told by Navalny later on, e.g. the name Maxim Sergeevich Ustinov was not really random. [1] https:/…

Best to take a look at the submitting usernames before making that assertion. There’s a lot of variety for this domain, mostly from established accounts. It’s a fairly popular website.

A variety of posters doesn't prove there is no spamming ring.

Re: The best books on assassinations

#27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Best to take a look at the submitting usernames before making that assertion. There’s a lot of variety for this domain, mostly from established accounts. It’s a fairly popular website.

A variety of posters doesn't prove there is no spamming ring.

Correct, but if you looked at the profiles of the submitters you would have immediately seen they were ordinary users, a few with a lot of karma.

I hate to disappoint but it really is just a popular literary site people like to share from time to time.

Re: The best books on assassinations

#30
When I was in Junior High / Early High School I went through quite the loompanics phase (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loompanics), buying lots of the books available there, including The Poor Man's James Bond, and several volumes of the How to Kill Series.

My stepfather was remarkably chill about it, considering our relationship, but maybe he didn't differentiate between those books and others as he never really understood the value of reading.

At any rate the only thing to come out of it (for those who worry) was that I got several talkings to when a rash of bomb threats hit our school. Maybe that was the first time I ever got put on a list!

on edit: I should probably mention that the books weren't very well written either, but I suppose literary quality was not on the top of their requirements list.

Post reply on HN