Live data from Hacker News

Japan's preference for hardware over software is fading

economist.com

21–30 of 43 posts

Re: Japan's preference for hardware over software is fading

#21
I agree that the software industry in Japan is deficient for lack of a better word in both quantity and quality. Mainly it's the result of a short-sighted bureaucracy running industry and education. Aside from the language barrier, which is formidable but manageable, Japan had all the ingredients needed to foster a thriving software industry (mainly a talented workforce schooled in science and a hardware manufacturing industry that could supply any and all the parts, at least in the 80s and early 90s).

The cultural obsession with making "stuff" or "monozukuri" is more a romantic notion nurtured by the economic slump as America made a massive comeback dominating every part of the IT field from hardware to software. Craftsman are highly regarded in Japan but great programmers see themselves as part of this tradition and peers regard them as such. It completely ignores the fact that the video-gaming industry and even anime is "soft" driven and a significant part of Japanese contemporary culture.

On the policy side there's just not enough support for entrepreneurship in general and more so for IT. Many of the first movers in the Japanese IT bubble crossed over into establishment quite quickly and the Livedoor scandal just provides government with a massive excuse to stay conservative. The fact that both Livedoor, Rakuten and SoftBank made hostile bids for media companies at one point probably did some damage as well in terms of turning traditional media against them.

Labor laws make it highly prohibitive to fire full-time workers and social benefits still tend to accrue to people who don't change companies. Of course, times are changing but policy still prevails. For any software startup in Japan hiring someone is hard because good people are conditioned to seek stability and hiring someone is risky for the startup because they are dealing with less talented people with the same employment guarantees. Although the IT industry in Japan mirrors general global trends to a degree, so there are more career changes, people are very risk averse and probably less mobile than a comparative sample from the states.

Also corporations tend to foster a false sense of homogenity which usually results in long hours and minimal incentives for performance. I've seen so many exceptional people, especially programmers, clash and ultimately burn against corporate culture. The rest go on leave for clinical depression.

In terms of education, the curriculum just plain sucks for science in general and for sciences more students flock to traditional engineering fields where the get to learn FORTRAN or COBOL and maybe play with R. Professors in Japan, even in the sciences, rarely lift a finger and many are completely inept with computers. Of course, younger professors aren't but with Japanese demographics they'll struggle to find tenure. Not to mention undergraduates don't study much compared to other countries since the entrance exam is the main event.

In terms of culture and language, Japanese allows for so much vagueness that I think it creates a serious barrier to clear and logical thinking needed for not only programming but interface design. People avoid debates of any kind and when they do occur, they quickly get emotionally heated. Also, a lot decisions for even the interface gets run by the committee or are consensus-based and that's not a good thing in general for design of any kind as you need a grand architect who knows what they're doing and can move with conviction.

I really can't do this topic justice unless I go and write a book so I don't think a short article by The Economist can address it either. Japan has a lot to offer too but those are my impressions on what's holding them back.

Re: Japan's preference for hardware over software is fading

#22
It is inevitable that hardware development cost is much higher compared to software especially at chip-level, in which the fabrication cost is getting higher and higher as the process node shrinks. Even the EDA tools used to design and develop the chip already cost a bomb. So, it is not surprising that the electronics firms struggle to reach 5% profit margin...

Re: Japan's preference for hardware over software is fading

#23

There are many interesting aspects about the Japanese arena. One of the most unforgiving is that users do not understand that their phones are connected to vast networks or that navigation system in their car is powered by a computer with memory, et cetera. When I first moved to Japan I asked normal people on the street to tell me what they found interesting about their phones -- I was shocked to learn that many Japa…

I totally agree with you. Another thing reading your comment is that lots of people don't own computers and only use the Internet through phones. This really screws kids out of a chance to mess around with computers. I know a lot people still get their first computers in college, especially women.

Re: Japan's preference for hardware over software is fading

#24
post #4

One of the things that really shocked me is how everyone still carries around electronic dictionaries when their cell phones should be able to fulfill that capability. The idea of one-function hardware is still deeply ingrained in the Japanese psyche in a way that it hasn't been for years in the West. As an American I always find it preferable to consolidate all my devices into one (which has turned out to be the cel…

As much as i'd like to have a universal device sometimes a well-crafted, well-designed, dedicated device is hard to give up once you are used to it. Would you rather use a TI-calc emulator on android or the actual device?

I'd rather have an HP-48G. Oh, I have two. And an HP48G emulator on my phone. RPN muscle memory runs deep.

Re: Japan's preference for hardware over software is fading

#26

I giggled when I realized that the author of this piece was in a hurry, and almost certainly thinks that Heroku is a Japanese company. "Marc Benioff, the boss of Salesforce.com, a large 'cloud computing' firm in Silicon Valley, sees opportunities everywhere in Japan. Over the past year the company paid $212m for Heroku, which develops web services based on Ruby, and acquired stakes in Synergy Marketing, Uhuru and Net…

Well that and the language (like their database offerings) and overall visual design of Heroku imply that it's a Japanese company.

Re: Japan's preference for hardware over software is fading

#27

There are many interesting aspects about the Japanese arena. One of the most unforgiving is that users do not understand that their phones are connected to vast networks or that navigation system in their car is powered by a computer with memory, et cetera. When I first moved to Japan I asked normal people on the street to tell me what they found interesting about their phones -- I was shocked to learn that many Japa…

Does this also explain why everyone still uses console BBS's in Taiwan? http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/ibbs/id309616952?mt=8

I've been trying to find an explanation for this.

Re: Japan's preference for hardware over software is fading

#28

I giggled when I realized that the author of this piece was in a hurry, and almost certainly thinks that Heroku is a Japanese company. "Marc Benioff, the boss of Salesforce.com, a large 'cloud computing' firm in Silicon Valley, sees opportunities everywhere in Japan. Over the past year the company paid $212m for Heroku, which develops web services based on Ruby, and acquired stakes in Synergy Marketing, Uhuru and Net…

Well that and the language (like their database offerings) and overall visual design of Heroku imply that it's a Japanese company.

Really? Suppose you went to a website for a similar kind of company but with a prominent Wild West theme, sheriff stars for buttons and products called Lasso and Six-Shooter. If I had to guess, I'd say that company was anything but American. Heroku's website oozes fanboy kitsch in much the same way. The difference is that a lot more technologists are Japanophiles than wannabe cowboys, so we don't notice as much and just lap that shit up.

Re: Japan's preference for hardware over software is fading

#29
post #15

One of the things that really shocked me is how everyone still carries around electronic dictionaries when their cell phones should be able to fulfill that capability. The idea of one-function hardware is still deeply ingrained in the Japanese psyche in a way that it hasn't been for years in the West. As an American I always find it preferable to consolidate all my devices into one (which has turned out to be the cel…

I'm in Japan. That's the wrong example. Cell phones came with a music player, rfid (your train pass, membership cards, and TVs long before the iphone). These electronic dictionaries come bundled with several different types like English/Japanese, Oxford, etc. that would cost you a small fortune separately and most are needed for college prep and college. Using a cell phone might work but for most adults but at school…

You're spot on. When I first saw Google Wallet, I thought, "haven't Japanese cellphones been doing this for a while?" Also, I have an electronic dictionary, a DS with a dictionary game, and a phone with a dictionary. I still prefer to use my electronic dictionary when possible. The reason is simply that it is by far the best. It has the most extensive dictionary (including many computer terms), more (quantity and quality) useful examples, it also has better features for jumping across dictionaries and makes it really easy to quickly look up other words in definitions, and finally, it has much better written Kanji recognition than the DS and phone. I imagine if a phone dictionary worked this well, people would use it. It's not like I carry it everywhere with me, but like flocial says, when I'm seriously studying Japanese, I prefer to have my dictionary.

Re: Japan's preference for hardware over software is fading

#30

I giggled when I realized that the author of this piece was in a hurry, and almost certainly thinks that Heroku is a Japanese company. "Marc Benioff, the boss of Salesforce.com, a large 'cloud computing' firm in Silicon Valley, sees opportunities everywhere in Japan. Over the past year the company paid $212m for Heroku, which develops web services based on Ruby, and acquired stakes in Synergy Marketing, Uhuru and Net…

Well that and the language (like their database offerings) and overall visual design of Heroku imply that it's a Japanese company.

The irony is that real Japanese company websites look nothing like Heroku. :-)

http://www.rakuten.co.jp/ http://www.biccamera.com/ http://www.sony.co.jp/

Post reply on HN