Live data from Hacker News

Explaining Google+ To The Norms

betabeat.com

21–30 of 41 posts

Re: Explaining Google+ To The Norms

#21

The "holes" metaphor doesn't really work; something can't be in more than one hole. Holes are also not an easier abstraction to understand than groups or sets. I think this article does a poor job explaining Google+.

I guess 'Venn Diagrams' wouldn't have worked with their target audience :-)

Re: Explaining Google+ To The Norms

#22
post #11
post #2

My wife has always been an intermittent Facebook user, because she was never sure how private anything was, and the periodic UI changes confused her. She's perfectly intelligent and reasonably technically savvy, but not a huge tech nerd, and not willing to invest time into figuring out all the nuances of FB. So I was really surprised when, after trying Google+ for a few days, she said, "I think this is really going t…

Will user A see my post? http://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-RIL_CvjOmVY/ThQKTNckBYI/AA...

The bottom right of that flowchart is a little scary. So anything you post, no matter how private you want it to be, can be seen by anyone that it gets re-shared to?

Nevermind: just noticed that that only applies to posts you share publically.

Re: Explaining Google+ To The Norms

#24
Reading the comments of this thread, I wonder if anyone actually reads the linked articles anymore. A bunch of discussions about why Google+ is better then Facebook etc... no one seeming to notice the article was comedy, and hilarious.

Re: Explaining Google+ To The Norms

#25
post #2

My wife has always been an intermittent Facebook user, because she was never sure how private anything was, and the periodic UI changes confused her. She's perfectly intelligent and reasonably technically savvy, but not a huge tech nerd, and not willing to invest time into figuring out all the nuances of FB. So I was really surprised when, after trying Google+ for a few days, she said, "I think this is really going t…

My wife and her friends (who amazingly all accepted her G+ invites and immediately started the service) like it much more than Facebook. My wife's an RN, and reasonably technically savvy, but not someone I'd call a "geek". I asked her why she liked it more and she said two things that I thought were interesting: 1) "Well, I like Google better anyway. So I'd rather use their service." 2) "It just feels better than fac…

This was nearly the same experience for me.

Background:

I am a rather technical person -- been messing with computers since MS-DOS 4 at the age of 8ish (sorry, not trying to show my epeen, just giving context) -- and was always apprehensive with social media.

Recently, when my work position became more of a project management position, I had to start getting to know Facebook -- which, previously, I've never touched at all before. This was about 2-3 months ago.

Starting with Google+, as a relatively new Facebook user, I just don't want to use Facebook anymore solely because of reason #2.

Re: Explaining Google+ To The Norms

#26
post #2

My wife has always been an intermittent Facebook user, because she was never sure how private anything was, and the periodic UI changes confused her. She's perfectly intelligent and reasonably technically savvy, but not a huge tech nerd, and not willing to invest time into figuring out all the nuances of FB. So I was really surprised when, after trying Google+ for a few days, she said, "I think this is really going t…

My wife and her friends (who amazingly all accepted her G+ invites and immediately started the service) like it much more than Facebook. My wife's an RN, and reasonably technically savvy, but not someone I'd call a "geek". I asked her why she liked it more and she said two things that I thought were interesting: 1) "Well, I like Google better anyway. So I'd rather use their service." 2) "It just feels better than fac…

wonder if a lot of people think of Android not so much as a Google thing but as an "off-brand iPhone"

Re: Explaining Google+ To The Norms

#27
post #3

"Like I could have a friend hole and an acquaintance hole and a K-hole. And they give you a list of friends and you stuff them in the hole, like Silence of the Lambs, except you are sending them images and text messages and hanging out with them on video chats." Totally family friendly ;)

I didn't understand why he said "K-hole". This kind of K-hole? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K-hole

Misery loves company

Re: Explaining Google+ To The Norms

#29
post #24

Reading the comments of this thread, I wonder if anyone actually reads the linked articles anymore. A bunch of discussions about why Google+ is better then Facebook etc... no one seeming to notice the article was comedy, and hilarious.

>A bunch of discussions about why Google+ is better then Facebook etc...

Deflection, a common strategy by those who have not taken a walk with Mark Zuckerberg. By changing the topic, they avoid the social discomfort that comes with acknowledging they were not woodsworthy.

Re: Explaining Google+ To The Norms

#30
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Will user A see my post? http://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-RIL_CvjOmVY/ThQKTNckBYI/AA...

The bottom right of that flowchart is a little scary. So anything you post, no matter how private you want it to be, can be seen by anyone that it gets re-shared to? Nevermind: just noticed that that only applies to posts you share publically.

Yes, any user that can see your post can reshare it to people you did not originally share it to by clicking the share button.

They could also just tell person A or repost it if there wasn't a share button, though. Just use good sense.

Post reply on HN