Live data from Hacker News

Synthetic Messenger: A botnet scheme for climate news

syntheticmessenger.labr.io

21–30 of 34 posts

Re: Synthetic Messenger: A botnet scheme for climate news

#21
As soon as they see how the extremely high CTR results in zero conversions on the landing ad page the value of such articles will go from something to zero.

If anything, this will devalue climate content in the eye of advertisers.

EDIT: No, seriously. This is *BAD*. It is technically interesting but super counterproductive and will have the opposite result of what it was made for in the first place.

Re: Synthetic Messenger: A botnet scheme for climate news

#23
This is exactly everything wrong with the internet in one neat little package:

* Polarized, politicized, incendiary topic? Check. * Unclear intentions? Check. * Media manipulation on a grand scale? Check. * Fake traffic to websites? Check. * Publishers scoring fraudulent clicks? Check (maybe) * Somehow, being awesome in spite of all of the above. Check.

Re: Synthetic Messenger: A botnet scheme for climate news

#25

I want to like this as an art project but just can't. Yes, it's interesting to point out that manipulating content algorithms to favor special interests is a reality. It would have been nice to at least acknowledge that this is generally not employed for wholesome causes. Mostly, though, this just literally doesn't work.

> It would have been nice to at least acknowledge that this is generally not employed for wholesome causes.

Right. They didn't quite manage to connect the circle. Their website needed to say something like:

> Corporate monoliths with a financial stake in destroying the planet have been employing these tactics for years, see [this] [that] and [those]. It's time to fight back.

Re: Synthetic Messenger: A botnet scheme for climate news

#26
This is horrible. This feels like the public isn’t interested in a topic as much like a group is expecting them to be, so the group fakes interest. It reads like “for your own good”. I predict that this will have zero impact on greenhouse gas emissions.

Re: Synthetic Messenger: A botnet scheme for climate news

#29

This is horrible. This feels like the public isn’t interested in a topic as much like a group is expecting them to be, so the group fakes interest. It reads like “for your own good”. I predict that this will have zero impact on greenhouse gas emissions.

It will actually increase emissions, since (a) advertising networks are extremely adept at detecting click fraud and will now downweight showing ads on pages about climate change and (b) botnets consume a ton of energy, and therefore release more greenhouse gases.
Post reply on HN