Live data from Hacker News

Apple employees call for company to support Palestinians in internal letter

theverge.com

21–30 of 51 posts

Re: Apple employees call for company to support Palestinians in internal letter

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s a combination of a few things: (1) Tech demands a lot from its employees. We are dedicating a significant portion of our waking hours. They expect us to believe in their mission, and so we also expect that mission to align with our values. (2) Technology itself is much more far reaching than any other industry. These corporations are massive, and with them massive budgets for lobbying etc. Not demanding that the…

>we also expect that mission to align with our values. "we" do? personally i expect my employer to provide financial compensation in exchange for me doing things for them. beyond that i don't really care about whether the giant corporation i work at is truly reflecting my core beliefs. i suspect that they probably aren't. > reflect the values of their employees do all employees truly feel the same way about every iss…

You left out an important part of the first sentence you quoted. Companies that expect employees believe in the mission end up with employees who expect a mission they can believe in.

Talking about employee values in aggregate doesn't imply all of them feel the same about every issue.

Re: Apple employees call for company to support Palestinians in internal letter

#22
post #2

Can somebody please explain to me this modern fashion of employees attempting to strongarm CEOs to publicly voice views irrelevant to the company's mission? I've been seeing a lot of this lately and I simply don't understand it. Should CEOs also be forced to publicly state that smoking is bad for you and recycling is good?

There is something special about being able to buy your food from the store and not having it be a political issue. I feel like we are slowly losing this. Commerce should really be separate from politics. Pushing politics into everything risks reducing cooperation between people and all these positive sum trades that naturally occur.

I’m looking forward to having to use a tracking app that will determine my price “discount” wether it’s positive or negative, and more importantly if I’m even allowed to even be there.

It’s been working great in China, and it feels like Yuu and other stupid things are going to bring it to Hong Kong so why not the west too?

Re: Apple employees call for company to support Palestinians in internal letter

#23
post #6

It’s about time the continuous flow of statements from big corporations around political (supposedly consensual) issues start to backfire. Just make your customers happy, don’t strongarm them, don’t overprice your products, and pay taxes, is all people are really asking from corporations.

This isn't a statement from a big corporation, though. This is a statement from employees of the big corporation (presumably all of whom feel comfortable leaving on a moment's notice) to the corporation.

Companies have long known that making your customers happy involves retaining skilled employees, and that incurring extra costs to keep skilled employees happy is worthwhile for the business. Sometimes that involves paying them well. Sometimes that involves putting San Pellegrino in the fridge. And sometimes that requires boycotting the State of Israel.

Re: Apple employees call for company to support Palestinians in internal letter

#24
The same Apple employees who got a petition together to get a Jewish employee, Anthony Garcia Martinez, who is unashamed of his support of Israel, fired? (I'll bet you wondered why he wasn't given consideration as a "latinx" employee. It's because he's Jewish.)

As Martinez said to Apple, "This will be your life now every week."

https://twitter.com/antoniogm/status/1395515386402021377

I still use an iPhone. I'm going to be moving away from it now. Apple Management needs to stand up to employees bullying them.

Re: Apple employees call for company to support Palestinians in internal letter

#25
post #18
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yup. Radio silence on that front for years. But it’s not just them, it’s many others on this new trendy virtue signaling dance until they later do something incompatible with their public statements and ignore it once again when called out. Perhaps Coinbase and Basecamp are the clever ones to resist accidentally signing up to the lifetime of demands from extremely politically charged activists that thrive from catchi…

My wish they’d all eventually gravitate to one particular state (Calif or NY, whatever) attracted by their common goal, do their thing there, let the rest of us work in peace and they can go on with their forever revolutionary activism to their hearts’ content till they realize that someone has to do actual productive work to ensure continuity.

As a New Yorker, I'd agree with you. My anecdata is that the activists are generally the most productive and engaged employees. Yours, I guess, is otherwise. We should just put this to the test - the activist leave the professional centrists alone, the professional centrists leave the activists alone, and we see who's better for business.

Re: Apple employees call for company to support Palestinians in internal letter

#26
post #25
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My wish they’d all eventually gravitate to one particular state (Calif or NY, whatever) attracted by their common goal, do their thing there, let the rest of us work in peace and they can go on with their forever revolutionary activism to their hearts’ content till they realize that someone has to do actual productive work to ensure continuity.

As a New Yorker, I'd agree with you. My anecdata is that the activists are generally the most productive and engaged employees. Yours, I guess, is otherwise. We should just put this to the test - the activist leave the professional centrists alone, the professional centrists leave the activists alone, and we see who's better for business.

It'd be nice to get some actual real-life results and this would get us there, so yeah, it'd be pretty nice if it happened.

Re: Apple employees call for company to support Palestinians in internal letter

#27
post #23
post #6

It’s about time the continuous flow of statements from big corporations around political (supposedly consensual) issues start to backfire. Just make your customers happy, don’t strongarm them, don’t overprice your products, and pay taxes, is all people are really asking from corporations.

This isn't a statement from a big corporation, though. This is a statement from employees of the big corporation (presumably all of whom feel comfortable leaving on a moment's notice) to the corporation. Companies have long known that making your customers happy involves retaining skilled employees, and that incurring extra costs to keep skilled employees happy is worthwhile for the business. Sometimes that involves…

Boycotting any nation is a political statement. Doesn't matter if it was employee pressure or not, it's still political.

Re: Apple employees call for company to support Palestinians in internal letter

#28
Glad they picked a simple issue where it's easy for everyone to agree on things. Presumably Apple will have an easy time resolving a conflict after the UN and US have repeatedly failed. ;-)

Given that Apple has a reasonably large R&D facility in Haifa and a fair amount of business in Israel, I don't see them disinvesting any time soon.

I could imagine them opening a Palestinian office and more stores though.

Re: Apple employees call for company to support Palestinians in internal letter

#29

Glad they picked a simple issue where it's easy for everyone to agree on things. Presumably Apple will have an easy time resolving a conflict after the UN and US have repeatedly failed. ;-) Given that Apple has a reasonably large R&D facility in Haifa and a fair amount of business in Israel, I don't see them disinvesting any time soon. I could imagine them opening a Palestinian office and more stores though.

Love this. Complete thread killer.

Re: Apple employees call for company to support Palestinians in internal letter

#30
Are any of these people interested in actually “building great products” anymore?

Whether you agree with them or not (I feel that companies should not take political stances in general), Are there no boundaries between work and personal beliefs? What happened to having your own beliefs and not forcing it on others?

Post reply on HN