Live data from Hacker News

Topology 101: The Hole Truth

quantamagazine.org

21–22 of 22 posts

Re: Topology 101: The Hole Truth

#21

I think this is a pretty good intuitive introduction. I think there’s a bit of muddling between the fundamental group and first homology group with the article: the algebra of the fundamental group where loops are merged together cares about the order you do each loop and I don’t think it’s intuitive that a + b = b + a for the torus, indeed I found this quite unintuitive when I learned it. Note that the group isn’t a…

Although you are right about the plane and sphere, a much earlier proof of them being not homeomorphic is obtained by simply stating one is compact while the other is not.

Re: Topology 101: The Hole Truth

#22
post #20
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That makes sense, I didn't realize we were allowed to stretch and bend however we want. Seems weird to be allowed to take a 3D object and contort it into 2D.

But it is not a 3D object, it is in fact a 2D object embedded in the 3D space. (So, what you are looking at is the result of an arbitrary “projection” of one into the other - a map, in mathematical terms.)

That helps me think of it
Post reply on HN