Live data from Hacker News

WhatsApp risks losing its most loyal customers: Indian uncles and aunties

restofworld.org

21–29 of 29 posts

Re: WhatsApp risks losing its most loyal customers: Indian uncles and aunties

#21
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's interesting. I read the title as an endearing and respectful way to reference the elderly in India. I hadn't personally encountered the 2(b) form you reference. When I was a kid, even an implied taunting of the older generation was forbidden, treated as stepping out of the bounds of social protocol, and would get you punished by your own parents or family if observed. Even now, as an adult, I would feel strongly…

I'm in my 40s, and my generation definitely has a derogatory sense of the term "uncles and aunties" - specifically an older generation of Indians who think it their right to be nosy and judgemental (and oftentimes even interfering) when it comes to the next generation's affairs. (in addition to the other usages msravi noted)

I'm in my 30s, and have been called that term online (in a sense akin to "OK Boomer")

Re: WhatsApp risks losing its most loyal customers: Indian uncles and aunties

#22
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are a few more nuances to this, probably depending on place and circumstance. 1. It's not necessary, for instance, that the person being referred to by the kid is "known". It's quite common, for example, for kids to address an unknown stranger on the street using "uncle" or "aunty" - it's merely a respectful way of addressing an older person. 2. When used by an adult, it can take on one of two tones: a) The gen…

It's interesting. I read the title as an endearing and respectful way to reference the elderly in India. I hadn't personally encountered the 2(b) form you reference. When I was a kid, even an implied taunting of the older generation was forbidden, treated as stepping out of the bounds of social protocol, and would get you punished by your own parents or family if observed. Even now, as an adult, I would feel strongly…

The derogatory sense of the term is widespread among the youth, who deploy it akin to "Boomer" in the US

Re: WhatsApp risks losing its most loyal customers: Indian uncles and aunties

#23
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm in my 40s, and my generation definitely has a derogatory sense of the term "uncles and aunties" - specifically an older generation of Indians who think it their right to be nosy and judgemental (and oftentimes even interfering) when it comes to the next generation's affairs. (in addition to the other usages msravi noted)

I'm in my 30s, and have been called that term online (in a sense akin to "OK Boomer")

Same here, though in my case i assume it's mock (hopefully?) insult in a few Indian Telegram groups where I'm the oldest member by about 2 decades. "Unkill" is the phrasing and "boomer" is most assuredly the implication.

Re: WhatsApp risks losing its most loyal customers: Indian uncles and aunties

#24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm in my 30s, and have been called that term online (in a sense akin to "OK Boomer")

Same here, though in my case i assume it's mock (hopefully?) insult in a few Indian Telegram groups where I'm the oldest member by about 2 decades. "Unkill" is the phrasing and "boomer" is most assuredly the implication.

"Unkill" was largely a Reddit India creation, where it runs rampant. Sounds like it has escaped the confines of Reddit and run amok.

Re: WhatsApp risks losing its most loyal customers: Indian uncles and aunties

#25
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are a few more nuances to this, probably depending on place and circumstance. 1. It's not necessary, for instance, that the person being referred to by the kid is "known". It's quite common, for example, for kids to address an unknown stranger on the street using "uncle" or "aunty" - it's merely a respectful way of addressing an older person. 2. When used by an adult, it can take on one of two tones: a) The gen…

It's interesting. I read the title as an endearing and respectful way to reference the elderly in India. I hadn't personally encountered the 2(b) form you reference. When I was a kid, even an implied taunting of the older generation was forbidden, treated as stepping out of the bounds of social protocol, and would get you punished by your own parents or family if observed. Even now, as an adult, I would feel strongly…

I suspect it depends upon context. Uncle and Aunty are an inherently respectful term, it’s just that kids do also use it ironically, reversing the meaning.

There are other words used like that, eg “mate”, which can be used in a friendly/neutral or menacing way.

(As a side note - I notice that Kamala Harris’s Twitter Bio currently includes “Auntie”.)

Re: WhatsApp risks losing its most loyal customers: Indian uncles and aunties

#26

Indian uncles and aunties who trust a WhatsApp forward because "internet" more than what actual scientists are saying. Essentially your Karens in WhatsApp university. They are loyal because for them, WhatsApp is the first time these millions of people got to experience internet. They dont know about stuff. They even remove their liability in spreading stuff by writing: as received I seriously believe if anyone at mat…

on a side note, liked your username. we definitely need faster internet in Kashmir valley so that the systemic cleansing , killing nd Exodus of Kashmiri Hindus by majority muslim population which was put under the rug for appeasement politics can be brought back to attention to ppl in the valley. noble cause.

Re: WhatsApp risks losing its most loyal customers: Indian uncles and aunties

#27

Indian uncles and aunties who trust a WhatsApp forward because "internet" more than what actual scientists are saying. Essentially your Karens in WhatsApp university. They are loyal because for them, WhatsApp is the first time these millions of people got to experience internet. They dont know about stuff. They even remove their liability in spreading stuff by writing: as received I seriously believe if anyone at mat…

on a side note, liked your username. we definitely need faster internet in Kashmir valley so that the systemic cleansing , killing nd Exodus of Kashmiri Hindus by majority muslim population which was put under the rug for appeasement politics can be brought back to attention to ppl in the valley. noble cause.

This is funny. I laughed.

Re: WhatsApp risks losing its most loyal customers: Indian uncles and aunties

#28

Indian uncles and aunties who trust a WhatsApp forward because "internet" more than what actual scientists are saying. Essentially your Karens in WhatsApp university. They are loyal because for them, WhatsApp is the first time these millions of people got to experience internet. They dont know about stuff. They even remove their liability in spreading stuff by writing: as received I seriously believe if anyone at mat…

on a side note, liked your username. we definitely need faster internet in Kashmir valley so that the systemic cleansing , killing nd Exodus of Kashmiri Hindus by majority muslim population which was put under the rug for appeasement politics can be brought back to attention to ppl in the valley. noble cause.

yes. i like it too. >we definitely need faster internet in Kashmir valley so that the systemic cleansing , killing nd Exodus of Kashmiri Hindus by majority muslim population which was put under the rug for appeasement politics can be brought back to attention to ppl in the valley. noble cause.

219 pandits were killed and that is called "systemic cleansing". bravo. you have outdone yourself.

from the same article on thehindu, not kashmiri propaganda,

>while 24,202 families were among the total 38,119 families which migrated out of the Valley due to turmoil

so out of 38k families who migrated, 14k were non hindus. 38% of all families who migrated werent even hindus.

24k families times 4 per is what? 100k persons who fled. what about millions displaced in afghanistan or syria or whatever. what about millions crossing into europe as refugees? no one is calling that as "systemic cleansing"

https://www.thehindu.com/news/ldquo219-Kashmiri-Pandits-kill...

please get your head out of your dictators ass for once

Re: WhatsApp risks losing its most loyal customers: Indian uncles and aunties

#29
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

on a side note, liked your username. we definitely need faster internet in Kashmir valley so that the systemic cleansing , killing nd Exodus of Kashmiri Hindus by majority muslim population which was put under the rug for appeasement politics can be brought back to attention to ppl in the valley. noble cause.

This is funny. I laughed.

https://theprint.in/pageturner/excerpt/right-wing-exaggerate...

this is what is being pumped into their veins. the utter hate because that hate apparently wins them votes in india and these people literally will sell their mothers for power. wink

i am not denying that wrongs have been committed. against both pandits and muslims but to say "pandit genocide" and "revenge for war crimes against pandits means to kill and maim remaining kashmiris because revenge"

apparently there are documented 100k killings by indian forces.

>The graves carry more than 100,000 of Kashmiris killed by state forces since 1989

http://kashmirwatch.com/kashmir-an-exotic-wonderland-under-b... This means at the very least 100K homes who lost their economic, social standing because the breadwinner is not alive.

and then the talk about 219 deaths as that is the entire issue and solving that would bring peace and harmony under indian oppression.

we have this phenomeon called "half widows" in kashmir courtesy india government.

https://kashmirobserver.net/2020/07/15/hoping-against-hope-h...

and the disappeared https://apdpkashmir.com/

Post reply on HN