Live data from Hacker News

Many don't have $2,000 for a rainy day

money.cnn.com

21–30 of 181 posts

Re: Many don't have $2,000 for a rainy day

#21
post #6

If you don't have enough money to handle an emergency, you have an emergency. Go ahead and panic. Trade your car for a cheaper one, move into a cheaper apartment, stop eating out, sell your TV, and get an emergency fund . If you're already living on toasted rats in a cardboard box, that's different, but if you've got unnecessary expenditures, you should really cut those out and get an emergency fund. To do otherwise…

[deleted]

Re: Many don't have $2,000 for a rainy day

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>I know the rule of thumbs is like 3 months net salary to keep for bad days I was under the impression that the rule was around 6 months.. then again, I'm talking about monthly expenses,as opposed to salary(which hopefully a person isn't spending 3 month's worth of salary in 3 months under normal circumstances). It probably goes up somewhat proportionally with age, if you factor in a home / dependents. I'm in the pro…

Six months salary is what I'd always aimed for. I managed that well until recently. Now it hurts.

I read your other posts and hope you are able to work toward better days sooner than later. I have to wonder though - if you hadn't been prudent before everything happened, how much worse off would you be now? Something of a rhetorical question, of course :)

Re: Many don't have $2,000 for a rainy day

#23
post #6

If you don't have enough money to handle an emergency, you have an emergency. Go ahead and panic. Trade your car for a cheaper one, move into a cheaper apartment, stop eating out, sell your TV, and get an emergency fund . If you're already living on toasted rats in a cardboard box, that's different, but if you've got unnecessary expenditures, you should really cut those out and get an emergency fund. To do otherwise…

Does having a credit card count?

What if someone has a $5k debt on a credit card, and only $1k in savings? Should they prioritize getting more cash into a low-interest savings account, while racking up interest on the CC?

Re: Many don't have $2,000 for a rainy day

#24
post #6

If you don't have enough money to handle an emergency, you have an emergency. Go ahead and panic. Trade your car for a cheaper one, move into a cheaper apartment, stop eating out, sell your TV, and get an emergency fund . If you're already living on toasted rats in a cardboard box, that's different, but if you've got unnecessary expenditures, you should really cut those out and get an emergency fund. To do otherwise…

You're looking at it from a middle class perspective. Unfortunately, most of these people are also deep in debt and have already made such cuts.

This is the byproduct of double digit unemployment as much as anything. As much as we talk about consumption, most of it is at the middle class level. Now, I've seen poor people make very bad decisions, but many are on purchases you and I would make without a second thought.

It is far too easy to forget how good we have it.

Re: Many don't have $2,000 for a rainy day

#25

One of the reasons the UK government bailed out the major banks here in the last financial crisis is that they feared what would happen if the retail banking system stopped working - if our chip-n-pin cards and ATMs suddenly stopped working. I did wonder if it might be sensible to keep a chunk of cash somewhere safe for unpredictable times - having plenty of cash on tap won't help much if it is tied up in a bank that…

Does the UK not have something like FDIC Insurance?

Re: Many don't have $2,000 for a rainy day

#26
post #11

I think it's very important to instill saving behaviors early on in your adult life. After graduating college, I had plenty of debt, but still made sure I was putting money into a savings account. Technically, it would have been much wiser to put any excess money towards 15% APR credit card debt than in 5% saving accounts (5% savings accounts did exist for a few years prior to the 2008 collapse), but actually having…

A lottery-linked savings account sounds awesome since I already play low-odds lottery and put money into savings every month. Texas won't give up their lotteries or multi-state lotteries for anything though.

Re: Many don't have $2,000 for a rainy day

#27
post #6

If you don't have enough money to handle an emergency, you have an emergency. Go ahead and panic. Trade your car for a cheaper one, move into a cheaper apartment, stop eating out, sell your TV, and get an emergency fund . If you're already living on toasted rats in a cardboard box, that's different, but if you've got unnecessary expenditures, you should really cut those out and get an emergency fund. To do otherwise…

Does having a credit card count? What if someone has a $5k debt on a credit card, and only $1k in savings? Should they prioritize getting more cash into a low-interest savings account, while racking up interest on the CC?

Unless you are carrying low/no interest debt you should really pay it off rather than put money into savings.

As long as your bank is not evil and keeps dropping your credit limit as your balance decreases you can always borrow again against that line of credit if needed.

Re: Many don't have $2,000 for a rainy day

#29
I use a Roth IRA for most of my long-term savings, can withdraw contributions very quickly with no penalty whatsoever. My investments are riskier but even if they tank I can still afford a $2000 type emergency. To me this makes more sense than wasting savings in a low-yield non tax-advantaged account.

Re: Many don't have $2,000 for a rainy day

#30
post #6

If you don't have enough money to handle an emergency, you have an emergency. Go ahead and panic. Trade your car for a cheaper one, move into a cheaper apartment, stop eating out, sell your TV, and get an emergency fund . If you're already living on toasted rats in a cardboard box, that's different, but if you've got unnecessary expenditures, you should really cut those out and get an emergency fund. To do otherwise…

Does having a credit card count? What if someone has a $5k debt on a credit card, and only $1k in savings? Should they prioritize getting more cash into a low-interest savings account, while racking up interest on the CC?

I currently don't have U$ 2.000 (not an American, but having money for a rainy day should be worldwide), but I could raise them with a (high interest) loan in about 30 minutes.

The article says they don't count, though:

"29.5% said they would have to resort to credit cards, a home equity line of credit, reverse mortgage or unsecured loan. "

Post reply on HN