Live data from Hacker News

Guide to Effective Reading

maartenvandoorn.nl

21–22 of 22 posts

Re: Guide to Effective Reading

#21

For what it’s worth, I’ve never met a successful academic or PhD who takes such a laborious approach to reading and taking notes for research papers. There’s not enough time in the world to spend four hours on one article, unless perhaps you’re a student ... and even then. I had one professor whose advice (specifically for occasions when someone was visiting to present a paper) was to read until you had a question to…

My experience with academics has been different.

The joke was that if you had ten papers to read, you'd spend ten minutes on all but one - and that one would take ten hours.

Re: Guide to Effective Reading

#22

For what it’s worth, I’ve never met a successful academic or PhD who takes such a laborious approach to reading and taking notes for research papers. There’s not enough time in the world to spend four hours on one article, unless perhaps you’re a student ... and even then. I had one professor whose advice (specifically for occasions when someone was visiting to present a paper) was to read until you had a question to…

My experience with academics has been different. The joke was that if you had ten papers to read, you'd spend ten minutes on all but one - and that one would take ten hours.

This was my experience as an RA in grad school. I could churn out paper summaries until I hit one that really challenged what I thought I knew about the topic and then I'd spend forever on it.
Post reply on HN