Live data from Hacker News

Launch HN: Rally.Video (YC S20) – Dynamic video platform for social groups

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 90 posts

Re: Launch HN: Rally.Video (YC S20) – Dynamic video platform for social groups

#21

One thing I'd recommend is to focus even more on dynamically updating the experience depending on the user's system resources. For instance if the browser starts crashing with too many video/audio streams, or bandwidth makes video basically useless, you could allow the user to participate in a conversation audio-only, or automatically turn off background audio to save bandwidth.

That is a terrific idea! Thank you

Re: Launch HN: Rally.Video (YC S20) – Dynamic video platform for social groups

#22
I think we've all seen various attempts to solve this issue over the years, but no one has quite figured out a decent UX to replicate the party experience. I'm glad to see you haven't gone the common & kind of intellectually-lazy route of moving an avatar around a virtual space.

Am I far off in thinking that the core challenge would be replicating the transition between sub-groups? That moment where you'd like to move on from a conversation and can gracefully step away without interrupting a conversation to announce your exit, walk through the room until you hear something interesting, sidle on up to another conversation without it feeling obtrusive, then join in.

I wonder if the abrupt nature of popping into someone's conversation with a new video-chat window would go against this. Either way, seems like an interesting puzzle to solve. Plus, the market is big, has a ton of attention right now, and any product has some inherent virality built in since some number of attendees will try it again afterwards. Very cool.

Re: Launch HN: Rally.Video (YC S20) – Dynamic video platform for social groups

#23

I think we've all seen various attempts to solve this issue over the years, but no one has quite figured out a decent UX to replicate the party experience. I'm glad to see you haven't gone the common & kind of intellectually-lazy route of moving an avatar around a virtual space. Am I far off in thinking that the core challenge would be replicating the transition between sub-groups? That moment where you'd like to mov…

We have been thinking about this A LOT. We actually have some ideas and I am happy to share them with you. Some include helpful nudges, permissions, a quick DM etc. Want to brainstorm or hear some more ideas? Happy to jump on a Rally call and throw some ideas around!

Re: Launch HN: Rally.Video (YC S20) – Dynamic video platform for social groups

#24

We've been using Rally for our happy hours, and internal meetings where there are more than ~5 people. It's great being able to easily hop between tables as conversation topics shift. It brings back a lot of that serendipity that we're all missing from in-person events. In fact, I find it allows for more serendipity than a lot of in-person events. In person, once you're sitting down at a table it's socially awkward t…

Thanks Tim!

Re: Launch HN: Rally.Video (YC S20) – Dynamic video platform for social groups

#25
post #8

I really love the idea and have been waiting for more apps to support these features! That said, I'm a little concerned about the business model. What's preventing the popular (and sometimes free) platforms such as https://whereby.com or https://team.video from adding these features?

You can add features but you can't really change your default behaviors without alienating your existing user base. If they're suddenly thrown into some wacky thing that they don't understand they will flood you with bug reports and subscription cancellations. So if you're approaching an activity from a fundamentally different point of view it's very hard for your competitors to clone.

Re: Launch HN: Rally.Video (YC S20) – Dynamic video platform for social groups

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Calla chat is super cool! Would love to talk to you about it!

https://gather.town/ is another. Probably one of the most solid right now. We're trying to take it the direction of conferences/tech events with https://meetfromhome.io/ .

Nice! would love to talk to you as well- ali@rally.video

Re: Launch HN: Rally.Video (YC S20) – Dynamic video platform for social groups

#27

Interesring! Enabling the social dynamics that naturally happen when large groups gather together, is something defenitevelly needed and the existing video conf solutions are too rigid to implement anything similar. Good job!

We've been experimenting with Rally on/off for a while. A lot of other attempts at this try to replicate physical space for larger groups (avatars wit WASD controls etc.), and that seems unnecessarily ham-fisted shoving a 3D experience on a 2D screen.

Rally was the first one that felt natural, to leave and join a table, and for there to be a natural speaker "on stage".

Next it would be cool to see if we would hold these calls persistently so we can capture some of the serendipity of hearing conversations one table over when in person.

Kudos to the Rally team!

Re: Launch HN: Rally.Video (YC S20) – Dynamic video platform for social groups

#28

I think we've all seen various attempts to solve this issue over the years, but no one has quite figured out a decent UX to replicate the party experience. I'm glad to see you haven't gone the common & kind of intellectually-lazy route of moving an avatar around a virtual space. Am I far off in thinking that the core challenge would be replicating the transition between sub-groups? That moment where you'd like to mov…

> kind of intellectually-lazy

I think that was rather uncalled for. My own use of avatars was a result of a lot of specific design decisions, around dissatisfaction with webcam video, i.e. the incongruity between the theoretical reason for why it's there ("to provide eye-contact!") and the reality that it fails at that task.

Re: Launch HN: Rally.Video (YC S20) – Dynamic video platform for social groups

#29
Hello Nice idea and amazing ui. if you convert your website in a native app with https://swaptoapp.com then you get more reach from app stores as well as play store. Like if you search on playstore for biolinky an app come. Swaptoapp.com also do same for your website and give amazing app in your email. Also you get daily visits as your website will stay as an app in users mobile so they can open it any time. Just think do you know the url of any website you visited on betapage two day's ago. I think you forget that but if you visit a site and then from that site you download that website app then it will stay in your mobile and after seeing for two three days you remind it forever. This is the feature of app. Also app gives an accessibility to your users. As typing a website url on browser is sometime boring and apartfrom that if you see towords an app it is easy to launch.

Re: Launch HN: Rally.Video (YC S20) – Dynamic video platform for social groups

#30
Is this only about talking to other people or does it allow shared experiences, such as watching a movie, playing games or watching a concert together?

I'm thinking about something like https://kastapp.co where people can do stuff together. It's easier to hang out with other people if there is something to do.

Post reply on HN