Live data from Hacker News

Luckysheet, an open-source spreadsheet

github.com

21–30 of 123 posts

Re: Luckysheet, an open-source spreadsheet

#21
post #13

A web-based spreadsheet, the code is under the MIT License, seems to have some (/many?) features of the commercial products.

Looks similar to every spreadsheet since Visicalc....

Fair point, updated my comment to give an idea what this is to someone like me who doesn't get right away what this.

Re: Luckysheet, an open-source spreadsheet

#22
Interesting, this suffers from the same issue I have with TeamViewer (and only with teamviewer; this Luckysheet is the first thing outside teamviewer I see this) on mac os x: if I scroll up in a document that has a vertical scrollbar, it will not only scroll up but also to the right. It happens on all the macs in the house, doesn't happen on Linux/Windows... Well, for Teamviewer; I did not test this one on all those machines yet.

The problem does not arise with VNC or any other remote tech or program. I have never figured why it is and it's been there for years across different macs and different OS X versions.

Re: Luckysheet, an open-source spreadsheet

#23

Interesting, this suffers from the same issue I have with TeamViewer (and only with teamviewer; this Luckysheet is the first thing outside teamviewer I see this) on mac os x: if I scroll up in a document that has a vertical scrollbar, it will not only scroll up but also to the right. It happens on all the macs in the house, doesn't happen on Linux/Windows... Well, for Teamviewer; I did not test this one on all those…

I have the same behavior here (MB Pro 13'', Catalina). But additionally I also experience that the scroll direction left to right is inverted. I have to scroll left so that the spreadsheet scrolls right and vice versa.

Not so top to bottom.

Re: Luckysheet, an open-source spreadsheet

#24

It looks really nice! But... The main reason I tend to avoid Google Sheets is that they're slow. Slow to open, slow to update more complex sheets, slow if you have more of them open. In general, much worse overall experience than a desktop spreadsheet, especially if you're using Firefox. So I was really hoping for something with the snappiness of EtherCalc (which is blazing fast!), just more elegant. I realize it's d…

thanks for this! I never knew something like Ether Calc existed!

There is also Etherpad: https://etherpad.org

Re: Luckysheet, an open-source spreadsheet

#25
Seems snappy enough on mobile, but translation of functions seems to be missing, so the formula editor is all in chinese to me. Not sure if that is plugable in runtime. One needs to at least translate src/function/functionlist.js maybe more..

This would all be easier if this was not a Vue app, but rather HTML5 but all in all not that different from how desktop apps are made.

Re: Luckysheet, an open-source spreadsheet

#26
I still cannot wrap my head around why so many folks want to use such applications in a web browser.

For me, web browser applications never reach the responsiveness and ease of use of well crafted desktop applications written in any decent systems programming language or even interpreted languages (not speaking of Javascript). Maybe I am getting old, but having the browser as a platform for programs is huge setback for many criteria that I personally value.

For example, as a free Excel alternative, I fall back to Gnumeric (http://www.gnumeric.org/) from time to time.

Re: Luckysheet, an open-source spreadsheet

#28

I still cannot wrap my head around why so many folks want to use such applications in a web browser. For me, web browser applications never reach the responsiveness and ease of use of well crafted desktop applications written in any decent systems programming language or even interpreted languages (not speaking of Javascript). Maybe I am getting old, but having the browser as a platform for programs is huge setback f…

> well crafted desktop applications written in any decent systems programming language or even interpreted languages (not speaking of Javascript).

These generally cost more money to develop/require ITs permission to be installed/get features slower.

Re: Luckysheet, an open-source spreadsheet

#29

I still cannot wrap my head around why so many folks want to use such applications in a web browser. For me, web browser applications never reach the responsiveness and ease of use of well crafted desktop applications written in any decent systems programming language or even interpreted languages (not speaking of Javascript). Maybe I am getting old, but having the browser as a platform for programs is huge setback f…

Sharing and collaborative editing. Being able to coordinate some process via a shared spreadsheet in a browser is efficient and resolves all issues of conflicting versions. Think of an overview of who is going to the office on which days this week (useful in times of working from home due to Corona).

Responsiveness is not the primary concern here: good enough is fine for most purposes.

This is not a replacement for a proper spreadsheet editor (I prefer LibreOffice myself); it's a tool to collaborate on tabular data with a group of people and minimal overhead.

Re: Luckysheet, an open-source spreadsheet

#30

I still cannot wrap my head around why so many folks want to use such applications in a web browser. For me, web browser applications never reach the responsiveness and ease of use of well crafted desktop applications written in any decent systems programming language or even interpreted languages (not speaking of Javascript). Maybe I am getting old, but having the browser as a platform for programs is huge setback f…

Because you never use the same desktop, I myself can use up to 10 different devices, it is always easier to access stuff from a webbrowser.

I do agree that the snappiness of Gnumeric is wonderful, and it's easier to do on desktop, nevertheless many desktop apps are worse than web apps.

Post reply on HN