Live data from Hacker News

The U.S. Has Officially Unflattened the Curve

time.com

21–30 of 53 posts

Re: The U.S. Has Officially Unflattened the Curve

#21
I have to say, living in NYC I'm pretty thankful for the quarantine requirement from anyone coming in from outside the tri-state area. I like to at least think we're on the downswing, although who really knows.

It's not like anyone will listen anyway, but it's a nice thought...

Re: The U.S. Has Officially Unflattened the Curve

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hopefully this undermines your belief that technical people are in some way immune to all the biases, emotions, fears, hopes and general humanity of people at large. Frequently, they're worse; they believe themselves to be hyper-rational cyborgs driven purely by evidence, giving themselves carte blanche to assume they're unaffected and thus don't even need to examine their own thinking. Yes, I too am a mental mess an…

The person you are approvingly replying to is overconfident and wrong.

The person you replied to deserves for you to reread their comment if you think they are "approvingly replying".

Re: The U.S. Has Officially Unflattened the Curve

#23
post #3

They don’t mention hospitalization or deaths. Those are the two to keep track of. I’m guessing far more people are getting tested than previously, hence the larger numbers.

Daily covid hospitalizations have doubled over the past month in Texas.

https://www.tmc.edu/coronavirus-updates/tmc-daily-new-covid-...

Re: The U.S. Has Officially Unflattened the Curve

#26

I have to say, living in NYC I'm pretty thankful for the quarantine requirement from anyone coming in from outside the tri-state area. I like to at least think we're on the downswing, although who really knows. It's not like anyone will listen anyway, but it's a nice thought...

FYI, only applies if coming from high-risk states. This included nine states originally. Not sure if further states have been added.

Re: The U.S. Has Officially Unflattened the Curve

#27
Need both raw and averages. But not ease for reporter. Stat telling “lies” and the truth at the same time. And said you have to dig in. Like % of test positive per test, death and hospitalised vs recovery. The fundamental is you want to use a number to say it all, but one number cannot tell the truth in many situation. One might not work, even simple like average vs median and mode. And a random bell shaped curve need two parameters.

Multiple angles are hard.

Re: The U.S. Has Officially Unflattened the Curve

#28
We. Shut. Down. Too. Early. In. Most. Places.

For the love of God. Texas didn't have an outbreak when they shutdown! Nor did Oregon, or California. That is the difference. All of Europe shut down _after the virus had already grown exponentially_ in most places. We shut down Oregon when there were fewer than 100 cases. After three months of being shut down in Oregon the curve had nowhere to go but up!

What in the hell did people expect? We shut down before there is spread, wait three months and then reopen. How is that a plan? Did anyone really expect that places where shutdowns were early and strong would somehow come out unscathed?

It has been true since day 1. You either need to shut down HARD until there is a vaccine (not possible, not sustainable, more deaths caused by this) or you deal with the surge of cases and do your best to protect the elderly/vulnerable.

What you don't do is panic, shut down too early, burn through all your money and political capital, reopen and then be all "golly gee there are cases now!". If we had waited until there was growth in cases, we could shutdown and actually flatten the curve enough to handle the shock to the system.

It is so. damn. frustrating. that this isn't more obvious to people. What materially changed between today and March 1?

Lockdowns where a bad idea from there start as there is no way to continue them until there is a vaccine.

I am very curious to see if NY and the other early hot spots avoid a resurgence like Europe has. That is what I am most interested now. If they do, perhaps the folks who are talking about cross-reactive immunity are on to something.

Re: The U.S. Has Officially Unflattened the Curve

#29

We. Shut. Down. Too. Early. In. Most. Places. For the love of God. Texas didn't have an outbreak when they shutdown! Nor did Oregon, or California. That is the difference. All of Europe shut down _after the virus had already grown exponentially_ in most places. We shut down Oregon when there were fewer than 100 cases. After three months of being shut down in Oregon the curve had nowhere to go but up! What in the hell…

I think the intent from the chief medical advisors (Fauci et al) was to slow the spread to the point where people would continue to get sick, but at a constant and manageable rate. But it's a very tricky thing, turning an exponential process into a linear one; especially when you don't actually know what the exponential is. Of course they couldn't come out and say this without being crucified, but I can't imagine that they simply didn't think ahead towards an outcome; doctors and researches are very much outcome-conscious. Unfortunately, our lovely politicians are, for the most part, math illiterate, and PR-conscious. So here we are.

Re: The U.S. Has Officially Unflattened the Curve

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The deaths are increasing too. 2500+ people passed away yesterday (June 25) in the US.

From all causes? Covid number is lower https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/us/

That can't be from all causes, there are around 8,000 deaths per day in the US from all causes.
Post reply on HN