Live data from Hacker News

U.S. is terminating its relationship with World Health Organization, Trump says

reuters.com

21–30 of 66 posts

Re: U.S. is terminating its relationship with World Health Organization, Trump says

#21

If the US pays a magnitude of money more than China to the WHO, how are we to believe that the WHO is China's puppet, and not an extension of western power? How is China so clever with its maneuverings that its relatively puny contributions go so far?

China puts the money directly into pockets whereas US puts money into WHO. Big difference.

Re: U.S. is terminating its relationship with World Health Organization, Trump says

#23

If the US pays a magnitude of money more than China to the WHO, how are we to believe that the WHO is China's puppet, and not an extension of western power? How is China so clever with its maneuverings that its relatively puny contributions go so far?

The theory goes (which I'm not espousing just relaying) that you could simply bribe top WHO officials and avoid having to provide magnitudes of money.

The WHO has been in scandal before regarding [exorbitant spending on travel.] (https://apnews.com/3d8569ea7bd140e4ba02bc1712cd12ab)

Re: U.S. is terminating its relationship with World Health Organization, Trump says

#24
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"wherever it originated in the world?" are you a CCP shill? it originated in China. Wuhan Province. It's not a mystery. And talk about not cooperating, that would be the CCP. Who not only destroyed all evidence on the ground but was and is unwilling to share any data with the world. Oh yeah, they also lied about the virus and how bad it was. They also got the WHO to say it wasn't a big deal and there was no person to…

It was in Europe as early as December 27: https://www.wsj.com/articles/coronavirus-timeline-is-upended... It doesn't even matter where the virus comes from. Why was South Korea able to handle it better than the US?

The origin of the virus can help immensely- for tracking, vaccination formulation, etc.

We have handled it atrociously here in the US, and the reasons were myriad. But it's disingenuous to compare nations, we all operate differently.

Re: U.S. is terminating its relationship with World Health Organization, Trump says

#26
post #23

If the US pays a magnitude of money more than China to the WHO, how are we to believe that the WHO is China's puppet, and not an extension of western power? How is China so clever with its maneuverings that its relatively puny contributions go so far?

The theory goes (which I'm not espousing just relaying) that you could simply bribe top WHO officials and avoid having to provide magnitudes of money. The WHO has been in scandal before regarding [exorbitant spending on travel.] ( https://apnews.com/3d8569ea7bd140e4ba02bc1712cd12ab )

I don't know if it's bribery at work here. Rather, it's anger at American behavior over the last decades which is pushing it closer to China. America is the WHO's primary superpower sponsor, and protector. In the courtship of a new sponsor, China, it could be just that: stoking anger and offering a choice.

Re: U.S. is terminating its relationship with World Health Organization, Trump says

#28
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The theory goes (which I'm not espousing just relaying) that you could simply bribe top WHO officials and avoid having to provide magnitudes of money. The WHO has been in scandal before regarding [exorbitant spending on travel.] ( https://apnews.com/3d8569ea7bd140e4ba02bc1712cd12ab )

I don't know if it's bribery at work here. Rather, it's anger at American behavior over the last decades which is pushing it closer to China. America is the WHO's primary superpower sponsor, and protector. In the courtship of a new sponsor, China, it could be just that: stoking anger and offering a choice.

I don't know either. I think all of this is obviously couched in the fact that the poor initial US response to Coronavirus has made it politically expedient to [make this a story about China] (https://www.foxnews.com/politics/gop-memo-advises-candidates...)

That doesn't mean the WHO or China have clean hands, just that in an election year for the US my bias would lean towards this being about politics.

Re: U.S. is terminating its relationship with World Health Organization, Trump says

#29

If the US pays a magnitude of money more than China to the WHO, how are we to believe that the WHO is China's puppet, and not an extension of western power? How is China so clever with its maneuverings that its relatively puny contributions go so far?

Because they've actually have been trying to manipulate this institution and the west has generally frowned on corruption in necessary institutions. Its one of the big things that is in the west core beliefs. This is why this is taken seriously. At this point, it would be against the US beliefs to manipulate the WHO so the only thing it can do is build a new one free of corruption from the ground up. It happens a lot.

Re: U.S. is terminating its relationship with World Health Organization, Trump says

#30
post #27

How does this make the US safer?

It gives the US the ability to create a non-corrupt institution. Right now the WHO is not a reliable global partner. If the US can find other people that feel this way you get a more efficient institution that possibly is more efficient.

Whats not safe is continuing to work with someone obvious playing fast and lose with the world.

Post reply on HN