Live data from Hacker News

Mozilla will remove FTP support in Firefox

ghacks.net

21–30 of 86 posts

Re: Mozilla will remove FTP support in Firefox

#21

I'm curious as to how many people use FTP in the browser?

I use it from time to time to download ISOs or source tarballs. It's handy not to have to use an external program for that.

I never seen a distro that didn't have a http mirror for those things myself. Even the ones that offer ftp.debian.org for example are accessibly over http as well.

Re: Mozilla will remove FTP support in Firefox

#24
post #2

Are there security issues with FTP, or do people just not use it enough because HTTP supplants it? I haven't used FTP in a while to download files.

The only FTP I use these days is really SFTP

Last I’ve checked SFTP was much slower than FTP unless you used the HPN-SSH patches. Is this still the case?

Re: Mozilla will remove FTP support in Firefox

#27
post #2

Are there security issues with FTP, or do people just not use it enough because HTTP supplants it? I haven't used FTP in a while to download files.

The entirety of changes to one of the files in the past 13 years is here: https://hg.mozilla.org/mozilla-central/log/tip/netwerk/strea...

There's more changes on nsFtpConnectionThread.cpp: https://hg.mozilla.org/mozilla-central/log/tip/netwerk/proto...

Looking at those changes, it's clear that there has been very little substantive modifications to the FTP code itself, as opposed to keeping up with style guide changes, mass renamings, and API changes. So either you believe this 15 year old code is really rock-solid, stable, high-quality code, or you believe that it's a massive pile of bugs and security holes that no one's examined too closely. I know which one I believe.

Re: Mozilla will remove FTP support in Firefox

#30

I love discussions about browsers on Hacker News! They're amazing. Half the people ranting how some insanely complicated technical decision is going to ruin the world, the other half yelling at them that this is necessary, others ranting about how the vendor is evil for some reason, etc. Just lovely!

You're going to love http://n-gate.com/.
Post reply on HN