Live data from Hacker News

I didn't want to fly – so I took a cargo ship from Germany to Canada

theguardian.com

21–22 of 22 posts

Re: I didn't want to fly – so I took a cargo ship from Germany to Canada

#21

Cargo ships are unregulated and burn the lowest grade oil called bunker fuel. These ships can emit the equivalent sulfur emissions of 19 million ICE vehicles.[1] [1] https://www.cadmatic.com/resource/articles/does-one-ship-pol...

Not as of January 01 - there's a new regulation this year that imposes a sulfur cap on fuel burned by cargo ships [1]. Most ships must now burn more expensive and cleaner fuels. Some ships - mostly larger ones - still burn HSFO but they can only do so because they've installed "scrubbers" which clean the emissions to reduce the amount of sulfur emitted into the atmosphere.

It's an open question whether scrubbers are really helping or just a diversion from purchasing higher quality fuel, but it's only economical to install scrubbers on the very big ships and so the large majority of the ~50,000 strong merchant marine fleet don't have them installed.

[1] https://ihsmarkit.com/topic/imo-2020-regulation.html

Re: I didn't want to fly – so I took a cargo ship from Germany to Canada

#22
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a point most media conveniently forget. Recently there was one that explained a train from Amsterdam to Barcelona costs € 350, takes 2 days and generates 45kg CO2. A plane costs € 100 (or less), takes 2 hours, and generates 200kg CO2. The option they forgot was a CO2 compensated flight, it costs € 110 (still 240 less than the train), takes only 2 hours and results in net 0kg CO2.

How do you compensate for the CO2 released? Do you contribute to some kind of CO2 removal project? Not being sarcastic or anything I just genuinely don't know how to compensate for CO2.

Yes, most airlines offer this option. There are two ways, one is buying the CO2 rights from someone else (that doesn't have a net positive effect on the world, don't do this if you really want to contribute something) the other is donating money to projects specifically to reduce CO2. Mostly that's tree planting projects, in areas that have had deforestation in the past.

There are a few organizations that audit these projects to guarantee they're actually planting trees and planting the right amount etc.

Post reply on HN