Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft has removed the “use offline account” option when installing Windows

reddit.com

21–30 of 800 posts

Re: Microsoft has removed the “use offline account” option when installing Windows

#21
post #8

I just want them to let me pick my own god damned name for the home folder. I hate the weird shit they pick for me.

why do people still use windows? It's stupid and naive to ask that, but I keep wondering why devs aren't successful in getting changes made at their companies.

It's a stupid question to ask, yes.

I work on macOS, but I have a Windows partition for gaming. Simple as that.

Other people need it to work. You might not like it, but it's a perfectly productive environment.

Re: Microsoft has removed the “use offline account” option when installing Windows

#22
post #2

“They have not removed it, it just is not visible by default if you are connected to the internet. Either run the setup without being connected to the internet, or type in a fake phone number a few times and it will give you the prompt to create a local account.”

>Either run the setup without being connected to the internet, or type in a fake phone number a few times and it will give you the prompt to create a local account.”

This is something I really can't see the average user doing honestly.

Re: Microsoft has removed the “use offline account” option when installing Windows

#23
post #13

I understand correcting the title to be more accurate to the situation, but I think the discussion should be focused on how Microsoft is taking power away from users, and has business incentive to do so. I don't like that the greater tech community rallies behind Microsoft for doing some basic contributions to open source and then hand waves away moves like this. Edit: the comment section has shifted and I'm less dis…

Open source contributions for Microsoft are just like charities for big corporations with despicable practices. They can use it to say "hey we are not that bad, after all we support FOSS!"

Re: Microsoft has removed the “use offline account” option when installing Windows

#27
post #7
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's no indication of magical behaviour, it's just unfriendly.

And it will end up being used by fewer people, after which their telemetry will indicate that fewer than X % of people are using the feature thus they will claim it's justified to remove it.

Yes, and I bet that data is what provoked them to start doing this already.

Even before this change you have to navigate out of your way to pick an offline account. It would be easy to think "oh, a large percent of users don't want local accounts" just looking at the telemetry data.

When really that's a given because the option is only going to be found by someone who knows beforehand that they want an offline account and fully expects it to be buried multiple menus deep in an advanced setting.

Microsoft was doing really good to gain developer traction with things like WSL, VSCode and the upcoming WSL2 release. But if they ever really do require a real account to use Windows, well... that's enough to cancel all of those things out to the point where die hard developers might just throw their arms up in the air and move to Linux even if it means making sacrifices for certain things.

Re: Microsoft has removed the “use offline account” option when installing Windows

#28
post #2

“They have not removed it, it just is not visible by default if you are connected to the internet. Either run the setup without being connected to the internet, or type in a fake phone number a few times and it will give you the prompt to create a local account.”

I guess they want to emulate Google chromeOS and Google is busy emulating MS of the 2000s. Shame.

Re: Microsoft has removed the “use offline account” option when installing Windows

#29
post #8

I just want them to let me pick my own god damned name for the home folder. I hate the weird shit they pick for me.

why do people still use windows? It's stupid and naive to ask that, but I keep wondering why devs aren't successful in getting changes made at their companies.

Visual Studio.
Post reply on HN