Live data from Hacker News

Purdue Pharma files for bankruptcy with $10B plan to settle claims

bloomberg.com

21–30 of 196 posts

Re: Purdue Pharma files for bankruptcy with $10B plan to settle claims

#21

SO what does this mean for non-US litigants, or future non-US litigants?

Well according to the WSJ, what's left of Purdue after the bankruptcy will be owned by a trust who's only purpose is to repay the litigants. So I imagine they'll just be part of that.

Also not all US based litigants are part of the settlement that is being worked out. There are also individuals who are being personally sued that aren't part of this as well.

Re: Purdue Pharma files for bankruptcy with $10B plan to settle claims

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The best outcome would be directing resources at preventing and treating opioid addiction, not at punishing the drug manufacturer.

That just sends the message that the rich can get rich by ruining the lives of however many thousands of people and will just seek new ways to get rich by ruining the lives of however many thousands of people.

I agree with you both.

Re: Purdue Pharma files for bankruptcy with $10B plan to settle claims

#23

Are the other manufacturers of oxycontin being sued too? I know that Purdue tried to underplay their role, but from the best #s I've seen they've only sold 20% of the market. https://www.statnews.com/2019/09/09/purdue-pharma-data-downp...

That's 20% of the whole opioid pill market, not just oxycontin.

As far as I know, generic manufacturers of off-patent drugs usually aren't sued.

On the one side, they don't actively promote/market their products to prescribers or patients, but I'd still think they share some blame by manufacturing it.

Re: Purdue Pharma files for bankruptcy with $10B plan to settle claims

#25
post #4

Looks like they got a golden escape hatch. Sounds like this arm of the company will end up controlled by a government trust. The best outcome would probably be the government running the operation at break even, lowering costs, and heavily regulating how much product it could give to hospitals.

Pierce the veil and go after the family.

They are wealthy Americans. They are untouchable.

Re: Purdue Pharma files for bankruptcy with $10B plan to settle claims

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pierce the veil and go after the family.

They are wealthy Americans. They are untouchable.

This is not true, the Sackler families have already put up $4 billion dollars of their own money as part of one settlement in this and they're still being sued by others not part of the settlement. There's also a criminal investigation into members of the Sackler family.

Re: Purdue Pharma files for bankruptcy with $10B plan to settle claims

#27
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Bankruptcy? What do you propose as an alternative when liabilities exceed assets?

Piercing the veil. This is not a lemonade stand going under. Here, "Liabilities" correspond to dead bodies. In the thousands.

What law permits this now; or are you proposing a new law? If so, how would it work?

Re: Purdue Pharma files for bankruptcy with $10B plan to settle claims

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The best outcome would be directing resources at preventing and treating opioid addiction, not at punishing the drug manufacturer.

That just sends the message that the rich can get rich by ruining the lives of however many thousands of people and will just seek new ways to get rich by ruining the lives of however many thousands of people.

Purdue never prescribed opioids to anyone. They only sold them to hospitals and doctors, after the FDA let them do it. Not sure what message punishing them is supposed to send?

But I get it. Someone dies and it’s the drug dealers fault, and punishing them will make everyone feel better. Except it doesn’t do anything about the actual problem (opioid addiction).

It feels to me like the elation here is because the Sacklers are rich and people really don’t like that, rather than any sort of victory in combating opiate addiction.

Re: Purdue Pharma files for bankruptcy with $10B plan to settle claims

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah this. I really wish there was some way to sentence these billionaires to the middle class for the rest of their lives. Some sort of "external" prison where their net worth is held to that of the median net worth of the OMB's "middle class" range.

Can we do it for everyone?

You mean everyone convicted of criminal misconduct? Or everyone everyone? Feel the latter would do more harm than good. The opportunity to become wealthy it a tremendous motivator.
Post reply on HN