Live data from Hacker News

Sick of cookie banners and popups? They’re all changing, again

silktide.com

21–24 of 24 posts

Re: Sick of cookie banners and popups? They’re all changing, again

#21

The article omits the really obvious solution: don't use all these cookies on your site. Many of us use google analytics for convenience but in reality there's really no reason for it on most sites. Basic login or technical protection measures are all perfectly fine - so storing an IP to make sure you're not getting ddosed is not an issue. This law is not aimed at the average homebrew website or restaurant menu page…

"It's for the big abusers, like Google".

If the law actually said that, it would be great.

You never want laws to be ambiguously applied and to presume exemption because "it wouldn't happen to me". People will abuse laws: there will be spam scams aplenty selling snake-oil solutions, and ambulance chasers threatening to sue companies because they can. Excess legislation comes at a cost.

I am in favour of better privacy but I fail to see how counting unique visitors on a blog should become a crime. By setting the standard that everyone is violating the law, you encourage everyone to ignore your law.

Re: Sick of cookie banners and popups? They’re all changing, again

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Would you trust that promise coming from a company whose bottom line relies on violating such promises?

It’s not about you trusting them, it’s about satisfying the requirements of the law.

If you don’t mind letting a malicious company stalk your users then by all means go and “satisfy the requirements of the law”.

Re: Sick of cookie banners and popups? They’re all changing, again

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s not about you trusting them, it’s about satisfying the requirements of the law.

If you don’t mind letting a malicious company stalk your users then by all means go and “satisfy the requirements of the law”.

Obviously around 0% of website owners do as they had to be forced into not pushing tracking cookies onto you by default. The decision is not mine to make as a user.
Post reply on HN