Live data from Hacker News

Ask YC: When did you start having interesting ideas?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 45 posts

Re: Ask YC: When did you start having interesting ideas?

#21

I was about six years old when I remember thinking to myself: I have a lot of great ideas. All I need is an 8 or 10-year old to help me make them cause I'm too young. I'm sure the ideas weren't that great, but the critical thinking is more important.

That made me smile!

Re: Ask YC: When did you start having interesting ideas?

#22
Could you point out some examples of this research? I guess it has something to do with events and routines being episodic memories, whereas abstract ideas is more of a metacognitive/executive task?

Actually, the ideas themselves would be declarative, if there were details involved. Now I'm confused. Would like to read about.

Re: Ask YC: When did you start having interesting ideas?

#23

Could you point out some examples of this research? I guess it has something to do with events and routines being episodic memories, whereas abstract ideas is more of a metacognitive/executive task? Actually, the ideas themselves would be declarative, if there were details involved. Now I'm confused. Would like to read about.

I'm not really sure what area of research this would fall under. The closest I can think of is "infantile amnesia," although that would be a stretch. As far as I know there is no established way to classify ideas, so that would make this a question not very well-suited for academic research. Actually, one of the reasons why I asked is because I'm interested in looking for patterns in what people consider to be interesting ideas. So far there are a lot of parallels with the answers that people here have been giving for the "what have you discovered" question, which is amusing, albeit not especially surprising.

If you are interested in infantile amnesia though, this paper is kind of interesting and gives a decent overview of the different theories:

Harley, K. & Reese, E. (1999). Origins of autobiographical memory. Developmental Psychology, 35, 5, 1338-1348.

Re: Ask YC: When did you start having interesting ideas?

#24

When I was 8 or 9 I came up with a basic design for a perpetual motion machine (it involved little dynamos on a track, and a ball running back and forth over them). No, I didn't use the term "perpetual motion machine". Anyway, I explained it to my mother who said it wasn't possible. Well, if I have a kid, I'm going to buy him some dynamos and tell him to build that sucker.

My fear is that, should I ever have a child, it will be completely uninterested in building, reading or learning, and therefore I will be out of my depth. My child would probably be a social butterfly.

In fact, I'm quite sure that this would happen. As jwz says, the universe tends toward maximum irony.

Re: Ask YC: When did you start having interesting ideas?

#25
post #4

You can have an interesting idea any time. Problem is you may not even realize that you just had an interesting idea when you had it. The journal is an excellent idea. I write everything down. When I look it over later, I'm usually embarrassed that I could have thought of anything so lame. But every once in a while, there are a few gems in there. I always have pencil and a small notebook next to the bed. The best tim…

So very true. I think experience gives you the knowledge to recognise when something can be done better because without it you just think that this is the norm and how things are. Throw in a dash of frustration just before "there must be a better way" and you have yourself an idea with determination behind it which is going to solve that problem.

I always have a bunch of paper in my back pocket for writing stuff down on the spur of the moment and then I develop the idea as a mind-map, sleep on it, and then develop it some more.

Re: Ask YC: When did you start having interesting ideas?

#26

When I was 8 or 9 I came up with a basic design for a perpetual motion machine (it involved little dynamos on a track, and a ball running back and forth over them). No, I didn't use the term "perpetual motion machine". Anyway, I explained it to my mother who said it wasn't possible. Well, if I have a kid, I'm going to buy him some dynamos and tell him to build that sucker.

A good friend of my father's reminisced about how when I was 6-7, I would show him my notebooks full of perpetual motion machines.

Re: Ask YC: When did you start having interesting ideas?

#27
Interesting ideas? I don't know, at least before age 8. I know that because at that age I was drawing designs for flying machines based on something I heard about a supposed link between electric charge and gravity... in other words, either pseudoscience or taken out of context (high-energy physics, maybe?).

I realized this when I built an apparatus to test it: a crude Van de Graff generator on a scale. I ran it for a while but despite building up a small charge (it ran on a 9V battery), the weight remained unchanged. I was disappointed.

Over time, my ideas have become more practical. Still, I occasionally have urges to create a bipedal robot or a better coffee machine :)

Re: Ask YC: When did you start having interesting ideas?

#28

Could you point out some examples of this research? I guess it has something to do with events and routines being episodic memories, whereas abstract ideas is more of a metacognitive/executive task? Actually, the ideas themselves would be declarative, if there were details involved. Now I'm confused. Would like to read about.

I'm not really sure what area of research this would fall under. The closest I can think of is "infantile amnesia," although that would be a stretch. As far as I know there is no established way to classify ideas, so that would make this a question not very well-suited for academic research. Actually, one of the reasons why I asked is because I'm interested in looking for patterns in what people consider to be intere…

According to my understanding of Piaget's developmental stages, the earliest a child can have "inventive" thought is in the concrete operational stage. Children enter this stage during school years, but before puberty. It's during this time that children begin to grasp basic scientific concepts like conservation of volume.

However, I didn't pay all that much attention in developmental psych, my textbook isn't handy, and the Wikipedia article is not all that helpful. :)

Re: Ask YC: When did you start having interesting ideas?

#29
I've found that interesting ideas come mainly from current life experiences combined with something that happened to you in your past. By this I mean current inspiration (ex: weekend snowboarding trip) that brought about a great idea for a product, then that idea is refined by your beliefs of what you feel a great product should really be. These beliefs are mostly derived from your childhood believe it or not. But most of all interesting ideas come from finding interesting things in the day to day grind.

Re: Ask YC: When did you start having interesting ideas?

#30

I've always found a lot of my ideas interesting; it's just that for most of them I eventually proved them to be bad ideas. Also, interesting ideas are rarely individual insights but usually come from merging two or more different ideas in a new way to create something genuinely cool.

"Also, interesting ideas are rarely individual insights but usually come from merging two or more different ideas in a new way to create something genuinely cool."

There you have it. It's hard to think of interesting ideas we had in the past because we tend to think of ideas as atomic, but those kinds of insights are pretty common and thus not so interesting, it's usually when you have a complex set of inter-related ideas that something really significant and interesting can emerge.

Post reply on HN