Live data from Hacker News

Girl flooded with beauty ads on Instagram

bbc.com

21–22 of 22 posts

Re: Girl flooded with beauty ads on Instagram

#21
post #7
post #2

> If you are an Instagram user and you would like to see which ad categories the platform has assigned to you, go to the settings menu in the app, then follow this path: Security / Access Data / Ads / Ads Interest. If the BBC wanted to be helpful, they could teach how to install uBlock Origin, instead of how to help corporate when their spying fails.

To be fair, as much as it doesn't help things, it is entertaining to see what Instagram thinks I like and is a feature I didn't know existed. I recently un-followed everyone besides the people I know IRL (so no more celebs, memes and instachicks) and, combined with the obfuscation software I use now, the ads suggestions are all over the place. For a male, 20-something year old nerdy engineer I apparently have a real…

People need to realise that these categories are not what web services use to target.

Instead, they are an approximation of the underlying data, which is really used for targeting.

Have an a analogy:

I have a photo of a crime suspect. I would describe it as "man with beard in yellow jacket".

When looking for the matching person, I could look for all other men with beards, or I could go back to the original photograph and try to find a matching face. What's likely to give the most accurate result? Clearly the face matching. They show you the text though, but underneath they use the face for the actual targeting.

Re: Girl flooded with beauty ads on Instagram

#22
post #20
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because it's the BBC, they have certain editorial responsibilities. It's one thing if they started a content series around digital rights, where adblocking extensions could be discussed. But this is a standard issue news story, so it's not appropriate to editorialize. Look on the linked page for links to external sites. Beyond the Twitter embeds and cancerous Taboola/Outbrain advert links, there are none. For regular…

How is mentioning the existence of ad-blockers, on a story about ads, editorializing? Meanwhile teaching you how to be a good consumer and set your ad preferences is 'neutral'?

From your original comment:

> they could teach how to install uBlock Origin, instead of how to help corporate when their spying fails.

That's quite a bit different from "mentioning the existence of", which would be reasonable IMO.

In any case, the elephant in the room that's gone unmentioned so far, is that the BBC introduced Google Ads on the site a few years ago, so it's probably not a priority for them to explain to users how they can block ads.

Post reply on HN