Live data from Hacker News

Indian government asks Apple and Google to take down TikTok app

economictimes.indiatimes.com

21–30 of 67 posts

Re: Indian government asks Apple and Google to take down TikTok app

#21
post #18

But why would the government be in in involved in banning apps. Don't we have more important cases pending.

I have no idea why people would want the government to step in. Forfeiting freedom because it's more convenient than being a hard-ass parent and not letting your child use the app or phone.

Re: Indian government asks Apple and Google to take down TikTok app

#22
post #14
post #8

"ByteDance’s applications TikTok and Helo are hugely popular among India’s teen and pre-teen population, especially in smaller towns. Many Chinese apps, including TikTok, have come under fire not only in India but also in the US, the UK, Hong Kong and Indonesia for content that is often dangerously close to exposing children to nudity and possibly those who seek to coerce or groom underage users into committing expli…

TikTok's argument is also relevant: In its petition to the Supreme Court [snip] The app was like any other social media platform, it said, adding that singling out TikTok was discriminatory and arbitrary.

Eroding freedoms based on "for the children" is a slippery slope but in this case I believe it is well justified. There is a gross amount of what I'd call sexual aggression in these apps between primarily older males towards younger, often underage, girls (and boys). Users treat these apps like porn sites, whether its to view public instagram photos, private messages, or even public comments. If you cannot police the worst of these activities I do not believe governments should allow companies to profit off them.

Re: Indian government asks Apple and Google to take down TikTok app

#23
post #18

But why would the government be in in involved in banning apps. Don't we have more important cases pending.

I have no idea why people would want the government to step in. Forfeiting freedom because it's more convenient than being a hard-ass parent and not letting your child use the app or phone.

There are certainly apps that should be illegal where the government should step in, right? Unless you're arguing that all apps should be legal?

Re: Indian government asks Apple and Google to take down TikTok app

#24
post #5

They didn't explain the actual reason until literally the last sentence

That's a fair sample of Indian mainstream media for you. Most of the stuff will be in the headline with some info sprinkled in the article.

Indian media? All media is like that.

Re: Indian government asks Apple and Google to take down TikTok app

#25
AFAIK India is TikTok's second largest market after its native China.

There's big money at stake here. ByteDance, the company behind TikTok, is one of the most valuable private companies in the world: its last fundraising round was at a valuation of $75 billion USD.

Re: Indian government asks Apple and Google to take down TikTok app

#27
post #13

TikTok is a Chinese application so I wonder if there are other interests at play.

There's a lot of Chinese investment in the Indian tech sector and the Chinese phone manufacturers basically own the Indian smartphone market. I don't see why they'd have problems with Chinese apps, in particular.

Re: Indian government asks Apple and Google to take down TikTok app

#28
post #2

Christ, that site is probably the worst ad-laden/features promos experience on mobile that I've seen.

Yep. Mindless advertising is huge in India because ad-blockers aren't really mainstream yet.

mirror: https://outline.com/7Fz8wB

Re: Indian government asks Apple and Google to take down TikTok app

#29
post #20
post #13

TikTok is a Chinese application so I wonder if there are other interests at play.

Check out Weibo, there's already a Proud Han army furiously attributing this ban to an Indian-American conspiracy designed to stop China's rightful rise. The reality is, if you are unable to prevent millions of your users from seeing videos of sexualized children you will get in trouble.

What separates Tik-Tok and other sites which also show millions of sexualized people like Instagram?

There obviously is a reason to be against China in this ban otherwise they'd ban a ton of other apps as well.

Post reply on HN