Live data from Hacker News

Shorewall – The End of the Road

sourceforge.net

21–30 of 70 posts

Re: Shorewall – The End of the Road

#21

Very impressive that this software was built and maintained by a mostly solo developer into their 70's. Talk about software lifecycle. I wonder if there is much of a community around this software and if there is someone who may take over the future direction, much like how Emacs' head maintainership was recently (relatively) given up by RMS.

He's been working on it for over 20 years...

Re: Shorewall – The End of the Road

#22
With all due respect, maybe he would have had better luck moving the community to another site

github certainly has its problems (feature bloat), but gitlab and bitbucket are options - as well as the new sourcehut

i have tried sourceforge a few times over the years and its just absolute garbage - from the forums to the issues to the source code - the only parts thats worth a damn is the binary downloads - and you can you bintray or a number of other places for that

any project that uses sourceforge for ANYTHING these days - even just docs - i dont touch unless i absolutely have to.

Re: Shorewall – The End of the Road

#23

Welp. I recently completed an Arch-linux and PCEngines-based DIY router build and stumbled upon Shorewall as an alternative to straight-up IP tables... I'm not looking forward to changing this setup.

I stumbled across a blog post that used Arch and Shorewall to roll a diy router. Any chance you used a blog post for inspiration and if so do you have the link still? I have been trying to find it ever since...

Re: Shorewall – The End of the Road

#24
Shorewall has been my goto firewall for years and still is. If any of you have ever followed my postfix howto [1] and others over the years, Shorewall has always been since 2005 the first thing to install and configure.

It fits the balance I need between powerful and ease of use (to my limited skill level). UFW seems too simplistic, straight IP Tables to cumbersome.

Either the community picks up the batton and I can still use Shorewall for years to come or I will have to start to try some of the alternatives :|

Thank you mr Eastep, and enjoy your trip.

[1] http://flurdy.com/docs/postfix/#config-simple-firewall

Re: Shorewall – The End of the Road

#26
post #22

With all due respect, maybe he would have had better luck moving the community to another site github certainly has its problems (feature bloat), but gitlab and bitbucket are options - as well as the new sourcehut i have tried sourceforge a few times over the years and its just absolute garbage - from the forums to the issues to the source code - the only parts thats worth a damn is the binary downloads - and you can…

I feel the same. When looking into some new linux distros out of curiosity, I'm noticing a trend that these new devs are putting it on source forge and immediately I am "turned off." Its not rampant but it has happened enough for me to hope this isn't going to be an escalating practice.

Re: Shorewall – The End of the Road

#27
post #22

With all due respect, maybe he would have had better luck moving the community to another site github certainly has its problems (feature bloat), but gitlab and bitbucket are options - as well as the new sourcehut i have tried sourceforge a few times over the years and its just absolute garbage - from the forums to the issues to the source code - the only parts thats worth a damn is the binary downloads - and you can…

Shorewall seems to use git for version control, in which case it doesn't really matter to the solo developer where the public repo is hosted. He's probably still on sourceforge because he doesn't want to give up nearly 20 years of messages he exchanged with his users. You can't migrate that to Github, can you?

If anyone adopts the project as their own, though, I hope they move to a platform where it's easier for others to contribute.

Re: Shorewall – The End of the Road

#28
post #23

Welp. I recently completed an Arch-linux and PCEngines-based DIY router build and stumbled upon Shorewall as an alternative to straight-up IP tables... I'm not looking forward to changing this setup.

I stumbled across a blog post that used Arch and Shorewall to roll a diy router. Any chance you used a blog post for inspiration and if so do you have the link still? I have been trying to find it ever since...

High likelihood it was this: https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Router

The Arch Wiki is pretty awesome, generally, and I used this pretty heavily as a reference. I will say, this was not 100% perfect and I had to use some other outside sources, but most of the info is here.

I did consider writing my own step-by-step post (if for no other reason than for me to not have to remember it), but haven't gotten around to it yet.

Re: Shorewall – The End of the Road

#30
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I stumbled across a blog post that used Arch and Shorewall to roll a diy router. Any chance you used a blog post for inspiration and if so do you have the link still? I have been trying to find it ever since...

High likelihood it was this: https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Router The Arch Wiki is pretty awesome, generally, and I used this pretty heavily as a reference. I will say, this was not 100% perfect and I had to use some other outside sources, but most of the info is here. I did consider writing my own step-by-step post (if for no other reason than for me to not have to remember it), but haven't gotten around to i…

I've never installed Arch and know virtually nothing about it but often the first link I click after googling is the arch one, their documentation is fabulous and pretty often bang up to date (Since I track Fedora N/N-1 the package versions are usually close enough).
Post reply on HN