Live data from Hacker News

Block Ads in Apps on Android

unlikekinds.com

21–30 of 150 posts

Re: Block Ads in Apps on Android

#21
post #4

How does it compare with Blockada? https://blokada.org

I've used both and Blockada is better mainly because it has a couple of killer features. One example is that it will keep the app alive, so that the power saving features of your phone does not kick in and turn it off.

Any experience with NetGuard? It has similar functionality and walks you through preventing the battery optimization from killing it.

Re: Block Ads in Apps on Android

#22

So you're sending ALL your internet traffic through a VPN, that you know nothing about? Sounds like the craziest idea I've ever heard. Who owns the VPN? What are they doing with your data?

...no?

You create a virtual "VPN" that filters out traffic based on hostnames. DNS requests that are not on the blacklist get forwarded to your DNS of choice.

Other adblockers for non-rooted Android (like NetGuard) work in the same way.

Re: Block Ads in Apps on Android

#23
Even at night when you don't use your phone, you are tracked and served ads. I use blokada and it blocks over 5000 ads and trackers in three days, 12 hours of effective usage, meaning 400+ ads/h: https://raymii.org/s/blog/My_phone_serves_me_400_ads_per_hou...

Blokada is easier to use that dns66, just one big button and you're done. It doesn't require root, but just like this app uses a local vpn (on the device itself, no servers involved).

For me it even blocks ads inside the YouTube app, which Adguard on iOS couldn't do...

Re: Block Ads in Apps on Android

#25
post #18

> This is a free, open source app. Open source is important here because all your network requests will go through this app, and we need to make sure we can trust it. Because the app is open source, if it was doing anything shady, it would be found out. That's the statement that always bothers me because it's only true if you build the app yourself. This is giving people a simplistic view and a false sense of securit…

If it's available on F-Droid, it can support reproducible builds, so that's at least one defense against it. https://f-droid.org/en/docs/Reproducible_Builds/

Re: Block Ads in Apps on Android

#26
I wish the play store would just let me filter based on app intrusiveness. Let me find things that don't use ads, don't have in-app purchases, and don't collect data. Looking at "paid" apps is NOT equivalent. Then I can maybe read reviews and get what I want. Once the quality bar has been raised I don't have any problem paying a few bucks (or more) for an app that behaves the way I want.

Re: Block Ads in Apps on Android

#29
post #22

So you're sending ALL your internet traffic through a VPN, that you know nothing about? Sounds like the craziest idea I've ever heard. Who owns the VPN? What are they doing with your data?

...no? You create a virtual "VPN" that filters out traffic based on hostnames. DNS requests that are not on the blacklist get forwarded to your DNS of choice. Other adblockers for non-rooted Android (like NetGuard) work in the same way.

Also limits your use of an actual VPN as well.

Thanks Obama!

Re: Block Ads in Apps on Android

#30

https://adguard.com has a similar approach using VPN. Would be interested to know if anyone has compared battery drain of the various apps

Well, it is not that similar. DNS66 is just a DNS changer/filter, AdGuard is a full-scale traffic filter and firewall: https://adguard.com/en/blog/adguard-vs-adaway-dns66/
Post reply on HN