Live data from Hacker News

The “.ro” Gold Rush (2018)

viorel.me

21–30 of 68 posts

Re: The “.ro” Gold Rush (2018)

#21
post #3

It's "unfair" to pay auction rates? How?

Why should the auction site get the domain to sell in the first place? A Romanian public asset is being basically dumped for 6 euros to a select group of private companies who then reap the rewards. It's not unfair between you and the other auction bidders, it's unfair between you and the auctioneer and the Romanian tax payer.

Re: The “.ro” Gold Rush (2018)

#22
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a private entity that reaps the benefits of what is a public good presumably...

A domain name is a private good, not a public good.

"A domain name is a private good, not a public good.... until it is sold (or rented) to person x, with the understanding that he can renew it forever if he follows a few rules.

Re: The “.ro” Gold Rush (2018)

#23
This just sounds like the old drop days, companies like snapnames, pool, namejet, godaddy have had backorders and snapping up as fast possible over APIs for ages. Only interesting bit is the policy change that caused it.

Re: The “.ro” Gold Rush (2018)

#24
post #18
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a private entity that reaps the benefits of what is a public good presumably...

it's not private until it have an owner. or are you normalizing the criminal behavior of godaddy where registrars can rush and buy the domain while you're doing the check out process just to sell back to you for more?

Citation for the GoDaddy claim?

Re: The “.ro” Gold Rush (2018)

#26
post #3

It's "unfair" to pay auction rates? How?

Economically, this is called rent-seeking behaviour. While perfectly legal, this feels unfair because the middleman adds no value whatsoever.

I'm not sure this really fits as rent-seeking. Usually, with rent-seeking, you manipulate either the political or economic landscape to give yourself a benefit without creating any value. In this case, resellers are taking advantage of a poorly designed system that was already in place to create a market for something that was being allocated stupidly.

And I think a key point here is that some form of this was inevitable. Even if they didn't set up the privileged API, you'd still have a glut of speculation, because that's what happens when you sell off a high value commodity below market. The only question is who is in a position to take advantage, and it doesn't seem from the article like resellers manipulated themselves into that position, so much as found themselves there by default.

Re: The “.ro” Gold Rush (2018)

#27
post #15
post #2

> If you want a really good domain, you can end up paying 500EUR per year for it. Can't you transfer it to a different reseller in the first year? You should be able to switch resellers with your domain. In worst case, you can start your own reseller.

I'm from Romania, and my firstname.ro was available late last year, but someone else bought it...I don't have a problem with that...I was willing to pay 50 euros, since it's a common name, I assume it went for a lot more. I don't understand why it would be 500 euros/year. Once you bought it, it's yours, you can renew it for 9/year.

I got firstname.be a while back, and I did pay more for it than 50 euros. Guess it depends on how much you want it -- I'd been waiting nearly 16 years until the domain finally expired. Didn't really feel like waiting another 16 years... :)

Re: The “.ro” Gold Rush (2018)

#29
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you ask for real or just troll? It is unfair because, because the domain costs 6€ if you’re the middleman and 300€ otherwise. I guess €3000 is not a super high entry barrier, but probably there is some red tape as well.

you see the value of a good, buy it and then resell it at a better price so you can make a profit. this is free market 101 as far as I'm concerned...

If the Romanian government knew what it was doing, it would be auctioning these domains itself and capturing the proceeds. If something is worth $500 but the government will sell it to a sufficiently credentialed and capitalized buyer for $9, that's very nearly free money for the lucky auctioneers.
Post reply on HN