Live data from Hacker News

The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

wsj.com

21–30 of 577 posts

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#21
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If a "credible" (read: state-approved) news organization had released those emails, would you have the same thoughts toward them?

News organizations wouldn't drop all the emails at once. Previous enormous leaks have been handled by ICIJ members with great care, going for years of investigations, careful verifications, and publishing only pertinent stories.

But there was an election around the corner, they can't be bothered with any of that.

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#23
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If a "credible" (read: state-approved) news organization had released those emails, would you have the same thoughts toward them?

News organizations wouldn't drop all the emails at once. Previous enormous leaks have been handled by ICIJ members with great care, going for years of investigations, careful verifications, and publishing only pertinent stories.

Why is that better than releasing all the emails at once?

Why do they get to decide what's "pertinent"?

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What was illegal about releasing campaign emails that were given to them?

When it was done with the intent of influencing the 2016 election, that tends to fall under conspiracy and espionage ... especially when it comes from a former adversarial government.

So then was it illegal when msnbc aired the infamous Trump video saying “grab them by the p...”? That was clearly meant to influence the election...

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think Freedom of the Press is dead. WikiLeaks isn't a news organization, especially when they released campaign emails during the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election. They have been to be a known tool for the Russian government, even going as far as creating a show for Julian Assange on the state-backed RT TV Network.

What was illegal about releasing campaign emails that were given to them?

Intentions and prior knowledge matter in a situation like this. It would be wise to see what information the prosecutors have before declaring the death of free press.

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#27
I never thought it would happen. He always seemed to stay a few steps ahead and he has plenty of of supporters and many countries that are hostile the US were willing to grant him asylum. I'm not sure how this would work. He would have to be kidnapped or given up.

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think Freedom of the Press is dead. WikiLeaks isn't a news organization, especially when they released campaign emails during the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election. They have been to be a known tool for the Russian government, even going as far as creating a show for Julian Assange on the state-backed RT TV Network.

What was illegal about releasing campaign emails that were given to them?

Some of the emails were altered by Russia for the purpose of spreading misinformation. Russia used Wikileaks to lend credibility to the conspiracy theories they were sowing in the run-up to the election.

NY Time has a great 3-part video series about Russia's history of spreading fake news. Each video is about 15 minutes but it's well worth the watch.

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think Freedom of the Press is dead. WikiLeaks isn't a news organization, especially when they released campaign emails during the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election. They have been to be a known tool for the Russian government, even going as far as creating a show for Julian Assange on the state-backed RT TV Network.

Yes, they are a news organization. Covering the election is what a news organization should do, and it's hard to argue the Clinton emails weren't newsworthy. >They have been to be a known tool for the Russian government, even going as far as creating a show for Julian Assange on the state-backed RT TV Network This is untrue. There is nothing suggesting that Wikileaks has knowingly coordinated with Russia. And that TV…

Covering news is much different than exposing the private communications of a political party.
Post reply on HN