Live data from Hacker News

We posed as 100 Senators to run ads on Facebook. Facebook approved all of them

news.vice.com

21–30 of 353 posts

Re: We posed as 100 Senators to run ads on Facebook. Facebook approved all of them

#21

"In announcing new transparency efforts or tools to combat foreign influence, Facebook included a caveat. “These changes will not prevent abuse entirely. We’re up against smart, creative and well-funded adversaries who change their tactics as we spot abuse,” Leathern wrote. But we believe that they will help prevent future interference in elections on Facebook. And it is why they are so important.” But posing as 100…

I wonder how many times "Zuckerberg" is in the code verbatim

I imagine one time. Then everything else imports the `MZ_CONST` file which then references the `MK` or `ZBERG` variables.

Re: We posed as 100 Senators to run ads on Facebook. Facebook approved all of them

#22
post #13

Facebook would not be where it is today if their programmatic advertising tools were not friction-less, it's going to be interesting to watch them balance ease of use for customers while securing their system vs. bad actors.

It is generous of you to assume that they will Secure their ad network against paying bad actors.

Re: We posed as 100 Senators to run ads on Facebook. Facebook approved all of them

#23
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

§ 11.432 Impersonating a public servant. A person commits a misdemeanor if he or she falsely pretends to hold a position in the public service with purpose to induce another to submit to such pretended official authority or otherwise to act in reliance upon that pretense to his or her prejudice.

That wouldn’t hold up in this case, because of that very important word “purpose”. They weren’t trying to get anything due to authority. In fact they were trying to make sure that Facebook was only approving ads by the actual authority.

Which is what I think parent was pointing out. Even if they ran ads saying "vote for me", it probably wouldn't fall under that language. They'd have to be inducing action in their official capacity, not as a candidate.

Re: We posed as 100 Senators to run ads on Facebook. Facebook approved all of them

#24
Do they have premoderation in ad system? I see lots of outright money scam and gambling ads in Instagram every day (in Russian language) (AFAIK, Instagram uses the same ad system as Facebook). Most of ads that I see in Instagram have pornsite-grade quality.

Re: We posed as 100 Senators to run ads on Facebook. Facebook approved all of them

#25

It's definitely a case of hanlon's razor for Facebook but it does show how easy someone with the right resources can exploit social networking sites to manufacture consent for example.

> It's definitely a case of hanlon's razor for Facebook but it does show how easy someone with the right resources can exploit social networking sites to manufacture consent for example.

It doesn't even look like you need the right resources, just the motivation and willingness to exploit it.

Re: We posed as 100 Senators to run ads on Facebook. Facebook approved all of them

#26
post #13

Facebook would not be where it is today if their programmatic advertising tools were not friction-less, it's going to be interesting to watch them balance ease of use for customers while securing their system vs. bad actors.

You have to give Facebook a copy of your ID, your SSN and wait for them to snail-mail you a code before you can get as far as Vice did. There's nothing friction-less about it.

Re: We posed as 100 Senators to run ads on Facebook. Facebook approved all of them

#27

"In announcing new transparency efforts or tools to combat foreign influence, Facebook included a caveat. “These changes will not prevent abuse entirely. We’re up against smart, creative and well-funded adversaries who change their tactics as we spot abuse,” Leathern wrote. But we believe that they will help prevent future interference in elections on Facebook. And it is why they are so important.” But posing as 100…

That's probably one of the only people they could actually be sure wasn't buying Facebook ads. Whereas a senator buying Facebook ads is, in itself, quite likely. Not really a fair comparison.

Re: We posed as 100 Senators to run ads on Facebook. Facebook approved all of them

#28

"In announcing new transparency efforts or tools to combat foreign influence, Facebook included a caveat. “These changes will not prevent abuse entirely. We’re up against smart, creative and well-funded adversaries who change their tactics as we spot abuse,” Leathern wrote. But we believe that they will help prevent future interference in elections on Facebook. And it is why they are so important.” But posing as 100…

That's probably one of the only people they could actually be sure wasn't buying Facebook ads. Whereas a senator buying Facebook ads is, in itself, quite likely. Not really a fair comparison.

Why wouldn't Zuckerberg ever buy Facebook ads? I doubt they'd let him run personal stuff for free, and I doubt they'd be sure he'd never want to run personal stuff.

Re: We posed as 100 Senators to run ads on Facebook. Facebook approved all of them

#29
post #13

Facebook would not be where it is today if their programmatic advertising tools were not friction-less, it's going to be interesting to watch them balance ease of use for customers while securing their system vs. bad actors.

It's not frictionless - all ads are approved. It takes some time and I don't think image and video approvals are entirely automated. I read in fact that a human being checks out every single one.

Re: We posed as 100 Senators to run ads on Facebook. Facebook approved all of them

#30
post #13

Facebook would not be where it is today if their programmatic advertising tools were not friction-less, it's going to be interesting to watch them balance ease of use for customers while securing their system vs. bad actors.

You have to give Facebook a copy of your ID, your SSN and wait for them to snail-mail you a code before you can get as far as Vice did. There's nothing friction-less about it.

Well normal ads you do not need to do any of that, you just need to have an account and a credit card. But yes for political ads you are supposed to go through their "Identity Confirmation and Authorization" process https://www.facebook.com/business/m/one-sheeters/ads-with-po...
Post reply on HN