Live data from Hacker News

Facebook confirms data sharing with Chinese companies

reuters.com

21–30 of 92 posts

Re: Facebook confirms data sharing with Chinese companies

#21
post #5

> “Every piece of content that you share on Facebook, you own and you have complete control over who sees it and how you share it, and you can remove it at any time,” This sentence has been bothering me because it feels like his lawyers wrote it. It's specifically worded to not include issues like this one. Ref: https://www.houstonchronicle.com/techburger/article/Zuckerbe...

How is it specifically worded to not include the issue? I just see that sentence as an outright lie. I thought it was notable for its lack of "weasel words" and disingenuousness that are the hallmarks of Mark Zuckerberg's speech. From the NYTimes article: >"But the BlackBerry app had access to all of the reporter’s Facebook friends and, for most of them, returned information such as user ID, birthday, work and educat…

But those are probably allowed to be publicly available by those users. Which is what Zuckerberg is saying in this statement. What he _isn't_ including in his statement is content created by FB about a person (used for marketing, etc.).

Re: Facebook confirms data sharing with Chinese companies

#22
post #5

> “Every piece of content that you share on Facebook, you own and you have complete control over who sees it and how you share it, and you can remove it at any time,” This sentence has been bothering me because it feels like his lawyers wrote it. It's specifically worded to not include issues like this one. Ref: https://www.houstonchronicle.com/techburger/article/Zuckerbe...

"you have control over ... how you share it". You do not have control over how Facebook shares it.

Re: Facebook confirms data sharing with Chinese companies

#23
post #7
post #4

How annoying Reuters included ads that redirect on mobile to pages informing me about viruses on my iPhone and an incredible huge lottery win. Too bad, it’s impossible to read the article on my phone. edit: mobile

That's why ad blockers are absolutely necessary. Not to scam companies out of their revenue, but because you cannot trust them in running clean ads. Fake virus alerts even are the lesser evil, delivering browser exploits or draining the battery by running crypto-miners are much worse. You read about such incidents every couple weeks...

On desktop, I use uBlock and Privacy Badger, but on my iPhone there doesn’t seem to be an option.

Re: Facebook confirms data sharing with Chinese companies

#25
post #23
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's why ad blockers are absolutely necessary. Not to scam companies out of their revenue, but because you cannot trust them in running clean ads. Fake virus alerts even are the lesser evil, delivering browser exploits or draining the battery by running crypto-miners are much worse. You read about such incidents every couple weeks...

On desktop, I use uBlock and Privacy Badger, but on my iPhone there doesn’t seem to be an option.

[deleted]

Re: Facebook confirms data sharing with Chinese companies

#26
post #23
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's why ad blockers are absolutely necessary. Not to scam companies out of their revenue, but because you cannot trust them in running clean ads. Fake virus alerts even are the lesser evil, delivering browser exploits or draining the battery by running crypto-miners are much worse. You read about such incidents every couple weeks...

On desktop, I use uBlock and Privacy Badger, but on my iPhone there doesn’t seem to be an option.

There are a few Add block options on iPhone what are they missing?

Re: Facebook confirms data sharing with Chinese companies

#27
post #5

> “Every piece of content that you share on Facebook, you own and you have complete control over who sees it and how you share it, and you can remove it at any time,” This sentence has been bothering me because it feels like his lawyers wrote it. It's specifically worded to not include issues like this one. Ref: https://www.houstonchronicle.com/techburger/article/Zuckerbe...

How is it specifically worded to not include the issue? I just see that sentence as an outright lie. I thought it was notable for its lack of "weasel words" and disingenuousness that are the hallmarks of Mark Zuckerberg's speech. From the NYTimes article: >"But the BlackBerry app had access to all of the reporter’s Facebook friends and, for most of them, returned information such as user ID, birthday, work and educat…

It specifically mentions information YOU post. Facebook collects metadata about you and your activities. That metadata is whats more dangerous... and conveniently unmentioned.

Re: Facebook confirms data sharing with Chinese companies

#28
post #4

How annoying Reuters included ads that redirect on mobile to pages informing me about viruses on my iPhone and an incredible huge lottery win. Too bad, it’s impossible to read the article on my phone. edit: mobile

I think this could be your network operator. Happens quite often to me on 3g in Germany, never when using wifi.

Re: Facebook confirms data sharing with Chinese companies

#29
post #15

Can someone explain to me a mechanism for having JSON data describing a user and all their information downloaded and then displayed on the screen of either an Android or iOS phone without the app or OS involved then having the ability to send that data to a server later on? The sentence “only available on the device” makes no sense to me as an engineer. What? Did Facebook code review every app and OS they gave this…

Exactly. All the issues these reporters are up in arms about would still be a problem if Facebook gave these companies access to their regular API instead of a specialized one.

In the end, a user is responsible for whom they give their username and password to. That includes typing it into an app. I hope we can redirect the publicity around this issue to scrutinizing the security of software, operating systems, and hardware. And promoting open source!

Re: Facebook confirms data sharing with Chinese companies

#30
post #4

How annoying Reuters included ads that redirect on mobile to pages informing me about viruses on my iPhone and an incredible huge lottery win. Too bad, it’s impossible to read the article on my phone. edit: mobile

I think this could be your network operator. Happens quite often to me on 3g in Germany, never when using wifi.

I am in the US at the moment and actually on WiFi, so I guess that’s not the issue.

But interesting that this happens to you. Never had that in Germany.

Post reply on HN