Live data from Hacker News

If you watch closely enough, everything is a speaker

kottke.org

21–30 of 54 posts

Re: If you watch closely enough, everything is a speaker

#21

Silly question: isn't this phenomenon bound by the Nyquist limit, which means it would take at the very least 4k fps to reconstruct music (considering that a soprano can get no higher than 2 kHz)? That sounds like an impossibly high framerate.

They show in the last demo usage of this technique with rolling shutter. Considering image height for most cameras is now in thousands of pixels, this somewhat overcomes Nyquist limit problem

Re: If you watch closely enough, everything is a speaker

#22

Silly question: isn't this phenomenon bound by the Nyquist limit, which means it would take at the very least 4k fps to reconstruct music (considering that a soprano can get no higher than 2 kHz)? That sounds like an impossibly high framerate.

They address that in the paper. They make use of the rolling shutter common in CMOS imaging chips to effectively increase the sampling rate to well above the frame rate.

Re: If you watch closely enough, everything is a speaker

#23
post #10

Here is the project page from 2014: http://people.csail.mit.edu/mrub/VisualMic/ And previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8131785 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9254654

Also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16201745

Re: If you watch closely enough, everything is a speaker

#24
post #5

Isn't this how those laser microphones work?

It's the same concept of detecting vibrations, but obviously this method is using a camera and processing a video, while the "laser microphone" [0] measures the difference in distance traveled by the laser beam.

It would be interesting to compare the two methods in various scenarios, i.e. through glass.

Obviously the laser method will work at night while the video method will not (probably depends how "dark" it is).

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_microphone

Re: If you watch closely enough, everything is a speaker

#28
Disclaimer: I work for a professional microphone manufacturer.

I wonder how long it'll be until this technique becomes feasible for recording professionally? Like, instead of capsules and diaphragms, we just have a laser that gets the cleanest, clearest possible signal it can, from the room around you ..

Re: If you watch closely enough, everything is a speaker

#29

Disclaimer: I work for a professional microphone manufacturer. I wonder how long it'll be until this technique becomes feasible for recording professionally? Like, instead of capsules and diaphragms, we just have a laser that gets the cleanest, clearest possible signal it can, from the room around you ..

Isn't one of the benefits of high-quality microphones that they can reject or attenuate the ambient sounds and reverberations that you do not want?
Post reply on HN