Live data from Hacker News

Going gray for smartphone addiction

gogray.today

21–30 of 66 posts

Re: Going gray for smartphone addiction

#21
I think it is bullshit, because black and white slot machine still is a slot machine.

[1]: https://www.theverge.com/2015/5/6/8544303/casino-slot-machin...

[2]: https://www.1843magazine.com/features/the-scientists-who-mak...

[3]: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/oct/05/smartphon...

[4]: https://venturebeat.com/2016/04/02/app-makers-its-time-to-st...

[5]: https://medium.com/@anamitra/dopamine-hits-and-product-desig...

Turned on grayscale in macOS(System Prefs - Accessibility - Display) before googling this articles, can confirm that still receiving dopamine hits.

Re: Going gray for smartphone addiction

#22
I have this thing called self-control and discipline. It doesn't cost anything except respect for one's self. Throwing technology and apps at character flaws isn't a long-term solution for anything and only feeds consumerism and materialism.

Re: Going gray for smartphone addiction

#24
post #20
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

hey sorry for the misunderstanding, i did link the wrong page. more context on https://gogray.today i give instructions for going gray on phones on the website, the app we're developing is desgined to make grayscale easier (whitelisting certain apps that is useful in colour, like google maps, etc).

The scrolljacking on that site is unconscionable.

i know :(, i've been tweaking it but cant get it to work (not a coder by trade)

Re: Going gray for smartphone addiction

#25
post #16
post #15

I started doing this yesterday. I kind of like it and I think I'm getting distracted less with grayscale. I'll unlock my phone and won't forget why I unlocked. You don't need an app for android to do this system-wide (tho I could see why whitelisting would be nice). Just go to developer options-> Simulate color space-> Monochromacy

yeah! we include the instructions on the website to go gray natively :). The app will have the features listed on the page.

For windows users, there's stuff like http://arcanesanctum.net/negativescreen/, that might be interesting to investigate and/or integrate into this.

Re: Going gray for smartphone addiction

#26
I did the native version of this after someone mentioned it in one of the general articles on phone addiction that have been making their rounds on HN since the start of the year. So far I don't feel like it has had much of an effect. I've only noticed two direct behavioral changes for me so far:

1) It is forcing me to wait to watch YouTube videos until I get to a computer because I want to see them in color. That seems like it should be a big gain, but I still find myself scrolling through my YouTube recommendations anyway. Habits die hard I guess.

2) It is also delaying my reading of the couple of web comics I follow since, again, I want to see them in full color.

So I guess my phone usage overall has dropped considerably since YouTube takes up most of my time. I'm already off Reddit starting a couple of months ago and I've been off of Facebook (except Messenger) and Twitter for over a year. So maybe I'm not really the target of all of this, but I definitely spend more time than I would like on YouTube.

I also made a change to my settings so that my phone screen no longer wakes up when a notification arrives. So it is less distracting when sitting on a table.

In addition I saw a couple of other pieces of advice on here to curb phone use: One of them mentioned putting only fast utility apps on your home screen and removing notifications that don't come directly from people (basically every notification except for personal e-mail, human texts, and Slack messages I guess?). I haven't tried either of those things yet but I'm definitely considering it. They both require a bit more thought and planning than simple settings changes.

In regards to the site linked, I have only one additional piece of input: Please stop with the scroll jacking. This is a well known web design anti-pattern. I don't understand why this fad has persisted as long as it has. It literally feels like the site is broken when interacting with it using a click wheel.

Re: Going gray for smartphone addiction

#29

I think it is bullshit, because black and white slot machine still is a slot machine. [1]: https://www.theverge.com/2015/5/6/8544303/casino-slot-machin... [2]: https://www.1843magazine.com/features/the-scientists-who-mak... [3]: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/oct/05/smartphon... [4]: https://venturebeat.com/2016/04/02/app-makers-its-time-to-st... [5]: https://medium.com/@anamitra/dopamine-hits-and-produc…

Ingrained associations don't die easily. I remember when I first quit facebook. I still had the habit of quickly pressing "F, enter" for months after I quit. After a couple years though, I hardly ever go through that old routine.

Check out Nicky Case's game about neuroplasticity: http://ncase.me/neurons/

Just now I enabled grayscale via the Android developer menu. I noticed an immediate reduction in intensity. It didn't feel like "bullshit" to me! If you want this to help you, you're probably gonna have to give it a little bit more of an open mind. The attitude of "this is bullshit" could very easily sabotage any positive benefits of this exercise. Big things grow from small seeds, but only if you water them, give them light and make sure they don't get crowded out by more aggressive plants.

Re: Going gray for smartphone addiction

#30
post #22

I have this thing called self-control and discipline. It doesn't cost anything except respect for one's self. Throwing technology and apps at character flaws isn't a long-term solution for anything and only feeds consumerism and materialism.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN