Live data from Hacker News

Jeff Bezos donates $33M to help DACA students attend college

thedream.us

21–30 of 33 posts

Re: Jeff Bezos donates $33M to help DACA students attend college

#21
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"If he has x billions of dollars he should give x billions of dollars" is what I get out of the comment. 33 million dollars is going to buy a truckload of TI calculators and other mandatory essentials.

Yes :-) I was trying really hard not to say something negative. But the guy's calculations appear to be out by a factor of 100, was my point.

Yep. Way off. Thanks for calling that out in a very direct and courteous way. I didn’t deserve that.

Re: Jeff Bezos donates $33M to help DACA students attend college

#22
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You and the other commenters are correct. I’m feeling quite guilty of being as cynical as I often accuse others on HN of being.

You're strong enough to admit it, so feel less guilty. I'm as cynical as anyone else, but you do have to step back occasionally and see nice things for what they are: nice.

I see this as very beneficial but I consider nice to be a very different thing. With that said I have a bad record on being reasonable so let me revisit this tomorrow after I’ve slept on it :)

Re: Jeff Bezos donates $33M to help DACA students attend college

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes :-) I was trying really hard not to say something negative. But the guy's calculations appear to be out by a factor of 100, was my point.

Yep. Way off. Thanks for calling that out in a very direct and courteous way. I didn’t deserve that.

Welcome. + I'm as scared of downvotes as the next guy :-)

Re: Jeff Bezos donates $33M to help DACA students attend college

#24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yep. Way off. Thanks for calling that out in a very direct and courteous way. I didn’t deserve that.

Welcome. + I'm as scared of downvotes as the next guy :-)

HN would be a very different place if downvotes weren’t a threat.

TBH I’m not sure whether that is good or bad. I’ve seen many threads go way down into a place that makes me sick and others that get stifled because the view is dissenting. More concerning are the threads that never happen because smart people know not to even bother getting into it.

On average I think things are OK though :)

Re: Jeff Bezos donates $33M to help DACA students attend college

#25
post #9
post #2

Great, but for context, if your net worth were $300,000, this would be the same as donating a dollar. Edit: my math is wrong as hell and I was being way too cynical. Sorry folks.

For some additional context, $33M will fund 1,000 college scholarships. That's 1,000 lives changed for the better - I would love to have that impact on the world.

But how many lives are worst because money was spent on Amazon?

Re: Jeff Bezos donates $33M to help DACA students attend college

#27
post #25
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For some additional context, $33M will fund 1,000 college scholarships. That's 1,000 lives changed for the better - I would love to have that impact on the world.

But how many lives are worst because money was spent on Amazon?

What do you mean? How many do you think?

Re: Jeff Bezos donates $33M to help DACA students attend college

#28
post #26

There are a ton of citizens who would benefit from college but can't afford to go. I struggle to see the utility in discriminating against your own poverty-stricken countrymen in this. What's the real motivation?

It's like donating to a charity. If you donate to one but not the other, is it discrimination to the other?

Re: Jeff Bezos donates $33M to help DACA students attend college

#29
post #26

There are a ton of citizens who would benefit from college but can't afford to go. I struggle to see the utility in discriminating against your own poverty-stricken countrymen in this. What's the real motivation?

What makes "our countrymen" so special and deserving over anyone else? Grow past the artificial box you were born in.

Re: Jeff Bezos donates $33M to help DACA students attend college

#30
post #26

There are a ton of citizens who would benefit from college but can't afford to go. I struggle to see the utility in discriminating against your own poverty-stricken countrymen in this. What's the real motivation?

Many Americans (myself included) believe most DACA recipients deserve citizenship, as they were brought to the U.S. illegally by their parents while still very young through no fault of their own. DACA recipients often consider themselves American, having grown up in U.S. public schools speaking American English and immersed in American culture. As young adults, the DACA program allowed them to pay taxes, hold down a job, pursue an education, and generally keep on being Americans.

In the view of DACA recipients as unfairly disadvantaged Americans, Jeff Bezos is indeed helping his own countrymen.

Post reply on HN