Live data from Hacker News

If you can't remember what domain(s) Sci-Hub is on why not make it all of them?

reddit.com

21–30 of 32 posts

Re: If you can't remember what domain(s) Sci-Hub is on why not make it all of them?

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How many hosts do you manage? Will your hosts file handle 1542 TLDs? Does your device have a configurable hosts file?

Is there any device people use for reading scientific papers that doesn't have a configurable hosts file?

Yes. An Android tablet with FBReader or Pocketbook.

Almost certainly a similarly configured iOS device.

(I use the former heavily. It is among the devices autoconfigured by the system described in the OP.)

Re: If you can't remember what domain(s) Sci-Hub is on why not make it all of them?

#22
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How many hosts do you manage? Will your hosts file handle 1542 TLDs? Does your device have a configurable hosts file?

Is there any reason for having 1542 TLDs that point to the same address instead of just one, other than wasting time trying to conform to invented but pointless requirements?

Yes: Demonstrating that the "we're gonna take your domains away" approach fails, and will result in backlash.

Re: If you can't remember what domain(s) Sci-Hub is on why not make it all of them?

#25

I use the Telegram bot. Very quick, always on, keeps a history, available on all devices.

Sorry, can you explain what this does specifically?

You install Telegram, you contact the bot https://t.me/scihubbot, you send him a DOI and it will answer with the PDF (if it has it).

Sometimes it says (in Russian) there is an error fetching the paper: I understand that in such a case it does not have the paper, but the paper is available on GenLib, so you can go there. But it is not frequent.

Re: If you can't remember what domain(s) Sci-Hub is on why not make it all of them?

#26
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there any reason for having 1542 TLDs that point to the same address instead of just one, other than wasting time trying to conform to invented but pointless requirements?

Yes: Demonstrating that the "we're gonna take your domains away" approach fails, and will result in backlash.

Demonstrating to whom?

Re: If you can't remember what domain(s) Sci-Hub is on why not make it all of them?

#27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there any device people use for reading scientific papers that doesn't have a configurable hosts file?

Yes. An Android tablet with FBReader or Pocketbook. Almost certainly a similarly configured iOS device. (I use the former heavily. It is among the devices autoconfigured by the system described in the OP.)

You can modify the hosts file on an Android device relatively easily.

Re: If you can't remember what domain(s) Sci-Hub is on why not make it all of them?

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sorry, can you explain what this does specifically?

You install Telegram, you contact the bot https://t.me/scihubbot , you send him a DOI and it will answer with the PDF (if it has it). Sometimes it says (in Russian) there is an error fetching the paper: I understand that in such a case it does not have the paper, but the paper is available on GenLib, so you can go there. But it is not frequent.

That sounds as if it's adding another layer (and possible failure mode) between you and Sci-Hub. How does the bot itself access the content? What keeps it from being attacked as Sci-Hub has, by publishers?

Re: If you can't remember what domain(s) Sci-Hub is on why not make it all of them?

#29
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes. An Android tablet with FBReader or Pocketbook. Almost certainly a similarly configured iOS device. (I use the former heavily. It is among the devices autoconfigured by the system described in the OP.)

You can modify the hosts file on an Android device relatively easily.

That's not been my experience.

Re: If you can't remember what domain(s) Sci-Hub is on why not make it all of them?

#30
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can modify the hosts file on an Android device relatively easily.

That's not been my experience.

It's the most common way of doing ad blocking on Android, you do it the same way as you would on a Linux PC. Of course, you need root, just like on a PC. There are apps that will do it for you even.
Post reply on HN