Live data from Hacker News

The decline of Stack Overflow

hackernoon.com

21–23 of 23 posts

Re: The decline of Stack Overflow

#21
post #3

“Closed as not a question”. “Tell us what you tried first. Nothing? Unacceptable!” I think they should have had a little more vision. I’ve closed two accounts. Now I only use my current account when absolutely necessary. I think I asked over 200 questions in my first two accounts. At one point I was trying to throw down breadcrumbs while learning elisp. https://stackoverflow.com/questions/2170528/writing-hello-wo...…

“that sounds like a homework question!!!”

I wish I was doing homework instead of struggling with an arcane production issue!

Re: The decline of Stack Overflow

#22
I wanted to reply to some questions below, but realised I've got more touchpoints than any single one of them.

Every now and again, I go through spurts of activity where I try and contribute to SO with reviews, comments, edits and answers (rep a bit below 2k). Two things happen every time I do this:

1. While there are lots of 'please do my homework' questions by new users, every now and again someone will post a question where they are genuinely trying to get their head around a concept as a new programmer, even though the question doesn't necessarily meet the MVP requirements, or could be seen as too broad or off-topic. I try and engage in the comments section, and quite often, it turns out to be a viable (but poorly asked) question, worthy of a good answer. The amount of aggressive downvotes, abusive comments, etc in these cases by other users (new and old) is absolutely astounding.

2. When I post answers, I try and tailor them to the OPs level, so it might not be 'by the book' accurate, but will explain the basic concept and offer a possible solution. For some reason, especially on C/C++ based questions, any answer that is not referencing the C/C++ standard and absolutely factually correct and accurate in terms of terminology, etc, will get aggressively downvoted, or destroyed in comments. What this has done, is to effectively stop me from even attempting answers in these categories.

So, yes, there are lots of 'bad' questions and 'bad' answers, but generally the voting and moderation system works. However, I think that 'older' users are as much to blame for some of the issues on the site, as new users who come there to have their homework questions done.

Re: The decline of Stack Overflow

#23
I come from the RTFM generation. S.O. never appealed to me, since I usually read the documentation of the libs/APIs/products I'm using.

Call me snob or whatever, but I'd rather rely on official (or good, comprehensive third-party) documentation. And if the product is open-source, you'd better ask the creators/maintainers and then contribute to improve the original documentation, for the greater good.

Post reply on HN