Live data from Hacker News

Standalone Signal Desktop

signal.org

21–30 of 320 posts

Re: Standalone Signal Desktop

#21
post #19

Signal Desktop is not really standalone, because you still need to pair it with your phone. And the phone should be turned on. I am very privacy conscious, and I don't use a smartphone, at all, because it's basically a spying device in your pocket. Why Signal is all about privacy and then it forces me to pair it with a telephone? Telegram desktop is really standalone. They require a telephone number too (and that's v…

Can you expand more on your personal decision to be so privacy conscious?

No.

Re: Standalone Signal Desktop

#22

I want to say "finally!" but they're deprecating the chrome extension so now my chromebook won't be connected anymore but at least I'll be able to get rid of chromium on my desktop. Guess you can never please everyone. But in all seriousness thank you for the great work, this is excellent news!

Deprecating doesn't necessarily mean you can't keep using what's already there. Even if it's removed from the store you should still be able to run it locally.

Not if Chromium removes support for packaged apps: https://blog.chromium.org/2016/08/from-chrome-apps-to-web.ht...

Re: Standalone Signal Desktop

#23
post #19

Signal Desktop is not really standalone, because you still need to pair it with your phone. And the phone should be turned on. I am very privacy conscious, and I don't use a smartphone, at all, because it's basically a spying device in your pocket. Why Signal is all about privacy and then it forces me to pair it with a telephone? Telegram desktop is really standalone. They require a telephone number too (and that's v…

Is Telegram as secure as Signal though?

Re: Standalone Signal Desktop

#24

I want to say "finally!" but they're deprecating the chrome extension so now my chromebook won't be connected anymore but at least I'll be able to get rid of chromium on my desktop. Guess you can never please everyone. But in all seriousness thank you for the great work, this is excellent news!

Deprecating doesn't necessarily mean you can't keep using what's already there. Even if it's removed from the store you should still be able to run it locally.

Also, hi, we both used to hang out in #teensonlinux back in the day! Always good to see handles from that old place randomly pop up

Re: Standalone Signal Desktop

#25
post #19

Signal Desktop is not really standalone, because you still need to pair it with your phone. And the phone should be turned on. I am very privacy conscious, and I don't use a smartphone, at all, because it's basically a spying device in your pocket. Why Signal is all about privacy and then it forces me to pair it with a telephone? Telegram desktop is really standalone. They require a telephone number too (and that's v…

Signal Desktop works without having your phone turned on. It acts like a full, independent client after linking it to your smartphone app (unlike WhatsApp, which does require your phone to be turned on).

Re: Standalone Signal Desktop

#26
post #8

Can we please stop calling Webapps that come with the whole browser desktop apps? The fact that you give me to install a dedicated browser for your web app does not magically make it desktop app. It makes it a worse web app, which does not even share the browser runtime with other web apps. Desktop apps are supposed to be: native code, well integrated in the OS, still working when the net is down and using system wid…

That might be your definition of it, but it's in general wishful thinking. For me desktop apps are apps that run on my desktop computer, requiring an installation process instead of being loaded via an URL and not subject to the browser's sandbox. I've had access or owned desktop computers in various shapes and sizes ever since 1993 and let me tell you, since then until now the notion that desktop apps have a unified…

> the notion that desktop apps have a unified look and feel is a really recent phenomenon, that happened due to Apple, OS X and the iPhone.

The Apple HIG dates as far back as the Macintosh. That’s 1987[0]. Visual and behavioral consistency have always been a staple of good design for those who cared.

[0]: https://guidebookgallery.org/books/applehumaninterfaceguidel...

Re: Standalone Signal Desktop

#27
post #25
post #19

Signal Desktop is not really standalone, because you still need to pair it with your phone. And the phone should be turned on. I am very privacy conscious, and I don't use a smartphone, at all, because it's basically a spying device in your pocket. Why Signal is all about privacy and then it forces me to pair it with a telephone? Telegram desktop is really standalone. They require a telephone number too (and that's v…

Signal Desktop works without having your phone turned on. It acts like a full, independent client after linking it to your smartphone app (unlike WhatsApp, which does require your phone to be turned on).

wow, sorry. my bad.

So I guess there is a way to use signal without having a phone nowadays! That's a great news!

I will try right now.

Re: Standalone Signal Desktop

#28
post #14

It's ludicrous that you need javascript enabled to download a secure messaging app.

For those that don't want to enable Javascript, these are the hidden Linux instructions:

  $ curl -s https://updates.signal.org/desktop/apt/keys.asc | sudo apt-key add -
  $ echo "deb [arch=amd64] https://updates.signal.org/desktop/apt xenial main" | sudo tee -a /etc/apt/sources.list.d/signal-xenial.list
  $ sudo apt update && sudo apt install signal-desktop

Re: Standalone Signal Desktop

#30
> Linux distributions supporting APT, like Ubuntu or Debian

Oh come on guys. Don't forget Fedora. Fedora means SELinux. SELinux means you are getting the people who value security.

Post reply on HN