Live data from Hacker News

Beauty in Mathematics: Modular Multiplication Tables

friendlyfieldsandopenmaps.com

21–26 of 26 posts

Re: Beauty in Mathematics: Modular Multiplication Tables

#21
post #5

These are definitely interesting. They make me wonder what the underlying continuous function is, and if it's the same function for all the pictures. These mostly look like aliasing to me. Which makes sense, perhaps is nearly obvious, because that's what you get when you plot the mod of a multiply on a grid. It's pretty easy to reproduce something close to the large image (prime 9973), by just plotting the continuous…

There’s not really a reasonable continuous analog, IMO (unless you just want to see a single solid blob, like in your picture, but that hides all of the interesting part of the structure). But there are moiré-like patterns. Check out https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qhbuKbxJsk8 for some insight based on a related type of diagram (related to a single row at a time from the OP’s diagrams).

That was awesome thanks for sharing. For the first minute I wasn't expecting much, but the reflections part was so cool! Plus, this connects directly to the cyclic curves in the complex plane, e.g., https://mathlesstraveled.com/2015/06/04/random-cyclic-curves... The curves formed by the envelope of intersecting lines in the circular multiplication table are a slice of cyclic curve space. I animated this after reading the above blog post: https://youtu.be/myGXoLCnx-A You can see some of the curves in the lower left corner are the same ones from Mathologer.

Re: Beauty in Mathematics: Modular Multiplication Tables

#22
post #3

how about general galois fields?

on a field you have two tables, one for sum and the other one for product, which one are you talking about ?

each of these tables is the table of a group, thus they will look like the tables of other finite groups

Re: Beauty in Mathematics: Modular Multiplication Tables

#23
post #3

how about general galois fields?

on a field you have two tables, one for sum and the other one for product, which one are you talking about ? each of these tables is the table of a group, thus they will look like the tables of other finite groups

As with prime fields, The additive group will look pretty boring. Are the multiplicative groups necessarily isomorphic to the multiplicative groups on (z/nz)*?

Re: Beauty in Mathematics: Modular Multiplication Tables

#24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

on a field you have two tables, one for sum and the other one for product, which one are you talking about ? each of these tables is the table of a group, thus they will look like the tables of other finite groups

As with prime fields, The additive group will look pretty boring. Are the multiplicative groups necessarily isomorphic to the multiplicative groups on (z/nz)*?

The multiplicative group is a finite abelian group, so it is certainly as "boring" as the additive group. The interesting pictures appear when you take into account a particular ordering of the elements of the group.

Re: Beauty in Mathematics: Modular Multiplication Tables

#25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As with prime fields, The additive group will look pretty boring. Are the multiplicative groups necessarily isomorphic to the multiplicative groups on (z/nz)*?

The multiplicative group is a finite abelian group, so it is certainly as "boring" as the additive group. The interesting pictures appear when you take into account a particular ordering of the elements of the group.

Yes of course lexicographic ordering is assumed, and the pattern will depend on the polynomial used to mod out multiplication. The boringness of the additive group presumes lexicographic ordering.

Re: Beauty in Mathematics: Modular Multiplication Tables

#26
post #7
post #4

Parametric equation for a hamburger: x(t) = Sin(Tan(t)) y(t) = Cos(t) Add a multiplier to x to get a submarine sandwich. Courtesy of Uncyclopedia.

Your burger, sir: https://www.dropbox.com/s/3iyakwegodne9gl/burger.jpg?dl=0 A fun side-note, zoom out to see this is an infinite burger stack, where every other burger is upside-down: https://www.dropbox.com/s/lz53ybz3pmchh9s/burgerStack.jpg?dl...

Cool! That's more of a 3D look. When I plot it I get a line drawing of a burger.
Post reply on HN