Live data from Hacker News

Quiet Hacker News

quiethn.com

21–30 of 62 posts

Re: Quiet Hacker News

#21
I would likely never use this. I'm almost always here for the comments on the Show HN & Ask HNs as well as the Stories.

The comments on the Ask HN, Show HN are usually very informative, and have helped me a lot in my own side projects and entrepreneurial pursuits.

The comments on stories (for me) act as a curation tool, and based on what I read, I actually decide to either read the posted story, or pass on it.

W.r.t. stories posted, 9 /10 times, the comments are more insightful and offer unbiased commentary that the original stories -- many of which (on the internets, not HN) are click-baity / shock'n'awe type posts -- often lack.

Re: Quiet Hacker News

#24

Why does it seem easier to scan the links on the front page of reddit than on HN? Often when I'm looking to upvote a link I just clicked on HN I will scan through all the links but miss the one I'm looking for. Is it the contrast and boldness of the titles that makes reddit better in this regard?

I think it's the background-colour. Every other link on reddit has a slightly darker background, which helps separate the links. HN doesn't have this, preferring to simply number the links as its way of differentiating

If one was so inclined one could make a custom css for HN. everyone has there quarks and can not make everyone happy.

Re: Quiet Hacker News

#25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wait, are you being facetious or did you not catch on to the fact that the comments not being included is what makes it "quiet HN"?

Your comment reminds me why "No Feigned Surprise" is a virtue ( https://www.recurse.com/manual#no-feigned-surprise ). Yes, it is entirely possible to miss the tiny link at the bottom that says "What is this?" and even then still possible to skim or dismiss it thereafter.

except there was no "Feigned Surprise" in the comment you respond to..

Re: Quiet Hacker News

#29
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even after your comment, I do not make that connection. If that was the intent, it fails...e.g, Why not duplicate the site faithfully and just eliminate the comment links? It succeeds in being 'quiet' (less noisy) in design.

I think it literally does exactly what you just said, content (posts) is duplicated, comment links are eliminated.

I'm not sure you know what "literally" and "exactly" means, after that comment. Stop using those words just because you disagree vehemently. Here's the "literal" version you haven't imagined:

https://imgur.com/a/hJTC2

Re: Quiet Hacker News

#30

Yeah I can understand the motivation for creating this. When I first started browsing HN, I couldn't believe how supplemental, civil and noiseless the comments were. However, after several years, I've started to jump straight to the comments, especially when I have a vague clue about what the article is about. That's when I don't feel the incentive to actually read and create my own opinions. I've also started to vie…

> I've since accepted that it is entertainment veiled as education.

Hacker News is neither entertainment nor education. It's just other people having conversations about a common topic of interest.

Post reply on HN