Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Angular vs. React vs. Vue

medium.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

21–30 of 77 posts

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#21

Post by Vinnl »

lolive wrote: post #11
akmittal wrote: post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think Google prefer either, YouTube was recently migrated to Polymer, They use Angular(Dart) from Adwords. almost all other projects use vanilla JavaScript(with closure compiler)

As far as i understand, Polymer (and Web Components, in general) permits to define custom HTML elements. What kind of custom elements are in the (insanely unreadable) Youtube main page?

The Polymer philosophy appears to be more of "make everything a custom element", i.e. up to the entire app (e.g. "", "", "", etc.).

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#22

Post by tzs »

In case the author reads the comments here, you've got a couple of annoying botched links.

The link in paragraph two to an alleged previous article of yours on choosing a tech stack gives a 404.

The link in paragraph three to an alleged blog post of yours on single vs multi page apps is actually just a link to the present article.

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#23

Post by hateful »

"If you love TypeScript: Angular" I would add an "(or Vue)" to this. When I first started out with Vue a month ago, there were some weird idiosyncrasies with typescript (IMHO). But the latest updates to "vue-class-component" and "vue-property-decorator" have fixed most of them.

tip: I believe they're still working on a good option in the current CLI (https://github.com/vuejs/vue-cli/issues/263) but one of the templates linked in that post (https://github.com/johnlindquist/vue-typescript-simple) is almost perfect (I had to make the following change that's in one of the reported issues: https://github.com/johnlindquist/vue-typescript-simple/issue...).

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#24

Post by ranit »

AbraKdabra wrote: post #20

I'm just really glad Vue is now included in every "X vs Y" framework, or "choosing a js framework", almost every article for the past two years have only been for Angular or React.

This started after recent Facebook decision to change React license.

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#25

Post by stephenhuey »

slackingoff2017 wrote: post #15
wiradikusuma wrote: post #9

I recently used both Angular 2 and React (the latter more recent) in some small projects. While I enjoyed working with React, I think Angular is more suited for me, a one-man startup. A lot of decisions are already made and I just follow them. In React, every time I need something not built-in (which is very often), I have to do some research, and even after deciding one, I have this "what if I'm wrong" guilt at the…

My biggest problem with Angular2 is how restrictive an obtuse the framework can be at times. I've ranted about it in other comments so I'll save space and just say that Angular makes easy things hard and difficult things nearly impossible once you step off the dotted line. Also the lack of a really solid UI library has caused many headaches. Material isn't very configurable, PrimeNg is okay but somewhat buggy and poo…

Aurelia will give you the flexibility you seek. Some UI toolkits now have integrations as well.

http://aurelia.io

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#26

Post by matrix »

wiradikusuma wrote: post #18
slackingoff2017 wrote: post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My biggest problem with Angular2 is how restrictive an obtuse the framework can be at times. I've ranted about it in other comments so I'll save space and just say that Angular makes easy things hard and difficult things nearly impossible once you step off the dotted line. Also the lack of a really solid UI library has caused many headaches. Material isn't very configurable, PrimeNg is okay but somewhat buggy and poo…

have you looked at https://vmware.github.io/clarity/ ?

I have, but it has had datepicker as "shipping real soon now" for at least six months. Not confidence inspiring.

Wouldn't it be nice if UI components (and just as importantly, their styling) was decoupled from the JS framework they're implemented with. Some kind of markup language perhaps...

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#27

Post by stephenhuey »

AbraKdabra wrote: post #20

I'm just really glad Vue is now included in every "X vs Y" framework, or "choosing a js framework", almost every article for the past two years have only been for Angular or React.

I think Vue is great but I wish Aurelia would show up in more of these comparisons as well:

http://aurelia.io

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#28

Post by nawitus »

lolive wrote: post #11
akmittal wrote: post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think Google prefer either, YouTube was recently migrated to Polymer, They use Angular(Dart) from Adwords. almost all other projects use vanilla JavaScript(with closure compiler)

As far as i understand, Polymer (and Web Components, in general) permits to define custom HTML elements. What kind of custom elements are in the (insanely unreadable) Youtube main page?

Did YouTube switch to Polymer yet? I think only the new design (https://www.youtube.com/new) uses it, and it's not yet switched on by default?

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#29

Post by mudbutt »

It drives me crazy when I hear things like Angular4+ is better for "Large Ambitious Applications with large teams" when in reality Angular4 suffers from the same slow down/performance problems as Angular 1.x.

https://github.com/angular/angular/issues/14041 https://www.airpair.com/angularjs/posts/angularjs-performanc...

I mean it's like they ignored all of the lessons and knowledge the industry has learned and produced a Framework that has issues built in! But I guess the Framework was designed with consulting in mind.

Re: Angular vs. React vs. Vue

#30

Post by atoko »

ranit wrote: post #24
AbraKdabra wrote: post #20

I'm just really glad Vue is now included in every "X vs Y" framework, or "choosing a js framework", almost every article for the past two years have only been for Angular or React.

This started after recent Facebook decision to change React license.

Can you expand on that?
Post reply on HN