Live data from Hacker News

IPhone 4 costs $188 to make

techcrunch.com

21–30 of 33 posts

Re: IPhone 4 costs $188 to make

#22
It doesn't cost $188 to make; it costs $188 for a buckets of parts :)

the 32GB iPhone 3GS used to retail in Australia for around US$850 ex tax. Assuming Apple's usual margin of 20-30% (let's say 30), and allowing another $50/unit for support/warranty issues, that puts the cost at something like $560 each.

Re: IPhone 4 costs $188 to make

#23
post #20
post #14

As another commenter noted, design, innovation, packaging, marketing, employees and obviously profit/taxes... aren't counted here. But yes, the iPhone is pricey if I compare it to other devices. For example, Google Nexus One have a better resolution, memory and processor that the 3GS, but the 3GS is more expensive. I don't bother paying $1K or more on a phone, but at least this phone comes with cutting edge technolog…

In what universe does this phone cost $1k or more?

Well... If you include the money you'll spend for being in contract for the next two years, you're probably well over $1000. But, I don't think the OP was trying to say the down payment on the phone alone costs $1000.

Re: IPhone 4 costs $188 to make

#24
Windows 7 costs $1.20 to make. 20 cent dvd + 20 cent packaging + 80 cent booklet (or whatever is in there.)

A high end CPU costs below $3 in material costs. (Numbers purely guessed)

Given these examples I find it wrong to accuse Apple for selling the iPhone at that price point. At least to me these "Product X costs Y USD in production" articles sound a bit accusing.

Re: IPhone 4 costs $188 to make

#25

It doesn't cost $188 to make; it costs $188 for a buckets of parts :) the 32GB iPhone 3GS used to retail in Australia for around US$850 ex tax. Assuming Apple's usual margin of 20-30% (let's say 30), and allowing another $50/unit for support/warranty issues, that puts the cost at something like $560 each.

The iPhone has a much higher profit margin. Considering they what they sell the iPod Touch for and how similar it is in parts, you can do the math yourself. (The Touch hasn't been updated in a while, so we'll need to see a Touch HD for a good comparison now.) They even give the Touch away if you buy a Mac for college.

Another thing, Apple charges more overseas. The 3GS retailed for a no-commit price in the states for $599/$699 depending on storage.

Re: IPhone 4 costs $188 to make

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thats not the point - this isn't an attack on Apple's pricing it's a typical industrial teardown BOM. You can get them for everything. Retail price is typically 2-4x BOM depending on how complex the product is and how long it will be in the market It's interest to the consumer is when a cell phone company is charging you $500 for the phone AND locking you into a contract.

(but, you know, they're not charging $500 AND locking you into a contract right?)

They are if you getting an early upgrade ($399/$499).

Re: IPhone 4 costs $188 to make

#27
post #20
post #14

As another commenter noted, design, innovation, packaging, marketing, employees and obviously profit/taxes... aren't counted here. But yes, the iPhone is pricey if I compare it to other devices. For example, Google Nexus One have a better resolution, memory and processor that the 3GS, but the 3GS is more expensive. I don't bother paying $1K or more on a phone, but at least this phone comes with cutting edge technolog…

In what universe does this phone cost $1k or more?

iPhone 4 32GB without a contract in the UK costs £599 which is about $900.

Re: IPhone 4 costs $188 to make

#28

Keep in mind that iSuppli's reports have been described (by daringfireball, as well as others: http://daringfireball.net/2007/07/isuppli ) as "bullshit". A lot of their price numbers (especially the ones for unusual parts, like the CPU and LCD in the iPhone 4) are pretty much pulled out of thin air.

Does John Gruber have any experience in building hardware that would allow him to reasonably claim any such teardown report as bullshit? Or did he just do some simple math in his head and think to himself that Apple doesn't make that much money so it must be BS? Hardware costs are just one piece of the puzzle, manufacturing/IP/shipping/R&D/software/marketing are others.

Re: IPhone 4 costs $188 to make

#30

Keep in mind that iSuppli's reports have been described (by daringfireball, as well as others: http://daringfireball.net/2007/07/isuppli ) as "bullshit". A lot of their price numbers (especially the ones for unusual parts, like the CPU and LCD in the iPhone 4) are pretty much pulled out of thin air.

The prices vendors quote are also, in a sense, pulled out of thin air. There is some floor to the price based on cost to produce and minimum acceptable margin, and volume also plays a role. But, there are many other factors that are subjective. For example, perhaps the part manufacturer is looking to get its first part into Apple, so they knock some more off the price.

While only Apply knows how much an Apple-proprietary processor costs, it is possible to estimate a cost for it based on process technology, die size, pin count, package, etc.

Post reply on HN