Live data from Hacker News

Ubuntu Reveal Results of Gnome Desktop Survey

insights.ubuntu.com

21–30 of 51 posts

Re: Ubuntu Reveal Results of Gnome Desktop Survey

#21
post #2

Users are split on whether window controls should be on the left or right. Hint: make it easily configurable. Otherwise, you get to irritate 40-60% of your users.

The key takeaway is _easily_ configurable. I don't want to have to drop into a shell and modify some XML file to do it.

Re: Ubuntu Reveal Results of Gnome Desktop Survey

#22
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would be very irritated if I couldn't put my bar on the left. I put it in the left on every UI I use. The reasoning seems sound though. Where there is no strong user preference, consider making it configurable. The only way you find out how irritated people would be without the option would be to piss them off.

Consider eclipse. It allows the user to configure every. Single. Thing. And in doing so makes configuration difficult because there are so many options. Sane defaults and a consistent environment are better, imho.

That's because Eclipse is basically an operating system like Emacs.

Re: Ubuntu Reveal Results of Gnome Desktop Survey

#23
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would be very irritated if I couldn't put my bar on the left. I put it in the left on every UI I use. The reasoning seems sound though. Where there is no strong user preference, consider making it configurable. The only way you find out how irritated people would be without the option would be to piss them off.

Consider eclipse. It allows the user to configure every. Single. Thing. And in doing so makes configuration difficult because there are so many options. Sane defaults and a consistent environment are better, imho.

Yeah. A great point. I do find eclipse to be too configurable, and part of why I use IntelliJ (for Java). Apple software is generally on the other end of that spectrum, which annoys many people; although you'll notice that even there you can put the bar on the left, right or bottom.

Re: Ubuntu Reveal Results of Gnome Desktop Survey

#25
post #16

Now that I think of it, what will happen with the Unity HUD (`alt` key brings a search hud that indexes the app's menu, kind of like Sublime/Atom/VSCode's Control+Shift+P command palette)? Will they port it as a Shell add-on? After using that for a while and switching to another desktop, I sorely missed it.

In Gnome it's the super key which does that. EDIT: scrap that, misread your comment

Re: Ubuntu Reveal Results of Gnome Desktop Survey

#26

Of the extensions they surveyed, the only one I really see as a must have is Top Icons Plus. That weird little corner tray that Gnome puts the legacy tray icons in is, well weird. It just seems so out of place. Of the rest of them, the only one I'd really loathe to see enabled by default is Dash to Dock. I really hate the that when I first log in to a fresh install there's a big static dock(initially filled with utte…

Dash to dock can be configured to disappear when a window is maximized. I personally can't use Gnome without it.

Re: Ubuntu Reveal Results of Gnome Desktop Survey

#30
post #16

Now that I think of it, what will happen with the Unity HUD (`alt` key brings a search hud that indexes the app's menu, kind of like Sublime/Atom/VSCode's Control+Shift+P command palette)? Will they port it as a Shell add-on? After using that for a while and switching to another desktop, I sorely missed it.

It relies on various hacky patches to e.g. gtk+2.x. There's an extension to add it to GNOME 3, but it still relies on those patches. Ubuntu planned to remove as many patches as possible. So with the extension and those patches it will currently be possible, but might not in future when they remove the patches.

So basically: maybe yes, maybe no.

Post reply on HN