Live data from Hacker News

Facebook flooded with 'sextortion' and revenge porn, files reveal

theguardian.com

21–30 of 81 posts

Re: Facebook flooded with 'sextortion' and revenge porn, files reveal

#21
post #18

I had a female friend last month whose ex-bf created a fake account and proceeded to set the profile and public photos and videos of them (having sex). He then went ahead and started sending friend requests to her entire family and friends. I felt so bad for her - it was awful enough to make her even have suicide thoughts. What really surprised me was how horrible the FB system to report stuff like this is. It is bas…

This isn't about FB solving the problem, it's about FB announcing the existence of their own internal bureaucracies. That is, they won't solve the problem, but they'll create an email address specifically for the problem.

Re: Facebook flooded with 'sextortion' and revenge porn, files reveal

#22
post #4
post #2

I am surprised their system for catching bad content is only user reports/flags. While revenge porn and stuff is bad, there are a number of known child related incidents. So if a private group of scumbags, are posting stuff to a private group, noone will know unless someone within reports. Who needs the darkweb when u can have a private Facebook group? Edit: as per replies below, they do use image recognition aswell…

I suspect they sign up to the IWF lists for filtering.

International Weightlifting Federation?

Re: Facebook flooded with 'sextortion' and revenge porn, files reveal

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, they use Magic Number among a bunch of various tricks. You can't really call it image recognition, more like 'data-hash comparison.' To train true image recognition would require a LARGE subset of stored illegal pornography.

What do you mean by "Magic Number" in this context?

It's in the file format

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_file_signatures

Also check out "libmagic"

Re: Facebook flooded with 'sextortion' and revenge porn, files reveal

#24
Some problems run deeper than their individual manifestations such as these for which one may propose techie solutions -- here, sex ed is the only permanent solution. It's time to find ways to explain to boys that sex is an ordinary way to have fun and/or connect romantically between adult people, rather than a source or arena of power or status as it is endlessly portrayed in media.

Re: Facebook flooded with 'sextortion' and revenge porn, files reveal

#26
So here's my thing: Imagine a world where facebook didn't exist. Would it have been impossible for this guy to get their photos and videos, post them on the internet?

I guess facebook does make it easier to email things to family and friends - but it only does so with the user's consent - you have the option to make your friends list private.

It seems to me like this guy is a real creep, and he should certainly be punished to the full extent of the law. But your friend also seems to have made a poor decision in allowing someone who is a creep to take very personal photos and videos of herself which could cause enormous humiliation.

The law should certainly step in to prevent stuff like this. But I question how much private companies should have to step in to protect people from their own bad decisions.

Yes facebook should certainly take effort to protect it's community standards and prevent porn and revenge porn as a part of it's duty to the community - but does facebook also have an affirmative duty to protect people from outcomes that are a result of their own poor life decisions? Does it owe an affirmative duty to your friend specifically to get rid of all revenge photos about her no matter whom she and how shares her nude or sexual photos? Or is there a duty on your friend to protect herself and exercise discretion in who she shares such content with?

Isn't there a duty on your friend to exercise discretion as to whom she sleeps with and whom she allows to take discreet photos and videos with. When she took these photos and videos, she knew there was a possibility that they may be used negatively, so does it negate her responsibility and become completely facebooks problem when those photos are abused by those who misuse their platform?

I mean imagine a case where this guy found her bosses and family's phone number and texted the image to her family? Does that then become AT&T's problem to go in there and clean up those images and moderate them?

Re: Facebook flooded with 'sextortion' and revenge porn, files reveal

#27

Some problems run deeper than their individual manifestations such as these for which one may propose techie solutions -- here, sex ed is the only permanent solution. It's time to find ways to explain to boys that sex is an ordinary way to have fun and/or connect romantically between adult people, rather than a source or arena of power or status as it is endlessly portrayed in media.

Sex and power/status are inextricably linked for much of society.

Re: Facebook flooded with 'sextortion' and revenge porn, files reveal

#28
post #20

So The Guardian puts this article up just as May's government is promising to tighten government restrictions on social media. That was convenient.

The Guardian isn't a right-wing paper, it's left of center, and I can't remember when it last endorsed the tories. You'd be far more likely to see that kind of thing from The Telegraph or The Daily Mail.

There's another explanation much closer to home which doesn't involve Theresa May: The Guardian, like many other newspapers, is under intense pressure from Facebook which is eroding their direct traffic in favor of traffic coming from FB. They literally compete against each other for clicks and ad traffic.

Re: Facebook flooded with 'sextortion' and revenge porn, files reveal

#29
post #18

I had a female friend last month whose ex-bf created a fake account and proceeded to set the profile and public photos and videos of them (having sex). He then went ahead and started sending friend requests to her entire family and friends. I felt so bad for her - it was awful enough to make her even have suicide thoughts. What really surprised me was how horrible the FB system to report stuff like this is. It is bas…

This guy is in the videos as well, right? Could she somehow strike back harder and demolish his reputation? Tell his friends and family, and his employer, what he did to her? Who the hell would send a video of themselves having sex with someone to that person's family?

Re: Facebook flooded with 'sextortion' and revenge porn, files reveal

#30
Facebook disabling 14,000 accounts in a single month because of that kind of terrible behavior does show this is a serious problem. But it's still a very rare problem. Given Facebook has 1.19 billion monthly users, that's on the order of 1 in 100,000 accounts.
Post reply on HN